Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

Objective profiling of perceived punch and clarity in produced music

Fenton, Steven and Wakefield, Jonathan P. (2012) Objective profiling of perceived punch and clarity in produced music. In: 132nd Audio Engineering Society Convention, 26th - 29th April 2012, Budapest, Hungary.

PDF - Accepted Version
Download (1MB) | Preview


This paper describes and evaluates an objective measurement that profiles a complex musical signal over time in terms of identification of dynamic content and overall perceived quality. The authors have previously identified a potential correlation between inter-band dynamics and the subjective quality of produced music excerpts. This paper describes the previously presented Inter-Band Relationship (IBR) descriptor and extends this work by conducting more thorough testing of its relationship to perceived punch and clarity over varying time resolutions. A degree of correlation is observed between subjective test scores and the objective IBR descriptor suggesting it could be used as an additional model output variable (MOV) to describe punch and clarity with a piece of music. Limitations have been identified in the measure however and further consideration is required with regards to the choice of threshold adopted based on the range of dynamics detected within the musical extract and the possible inclusion of a gate as utilised in some loudness algorithms.

▼ Jump to Download Statistics
Item Type: Conference or Workshop Item (Paper)
Uncontrolled Keywords: Punch Clarity Objective Measurement Produced Music Loudness
Subjects: M Music and Books on Music > M Music
T Technology > T Technology (General)
Schools: School of Computing and Engineering
School of Computing and Engineering > Music Technology and Production Research Group
Related URLs:

E.Skovenborg and T.Lund, Loudness
descriptors to characterize programs and
music tracks, AES Convention Paper
7514, October 2008

E.Skovenborg and S.H.Nielsen, Evaluation
of Different Loudness Models with Music
and Speech Material, AES 117th
Convention, San Francisco, CA, USA,
October 2004

ITU-R BS.1770, Algorithms to measure
audio programme loudness and true-peak
audio level, International
Telecommunications Union, Geneva,
Switzerland, 2006

Voxengo Gliss EQ,
[accessed 3rd January, 2012]

Fab Filter, Pro Q Equalizer,
[accessed 8th January 2012]

Pleasurize sound meter, [accessed
20th November 2011]

EBU-R128, Loudness normalisation and
permitted maximum level of audio signals,
EBU PLoud Group, August 2011

AC-R128 Loudness meter,
[accessed 8th January 2012]

Vis-LM-H, NuGen Audio Loudness Meter
with history,
ss-meter_VST_AU_RTAS.php [accessed
2nd February, 2012]

G.Ballou “Handbook for sound engineers”,
3rd Edition, Gulf Professional Publishing,
April 2005

E.Gonzalez and J. D. Reiss, "Automatic
equalization of multi-channel audio using
cross-adaptive methods", Proceedings of
the 127th AES Convention, New York,
October 2009

D.Barry, D.Fitzgerald, E.Coyle and B.
Lawlor, Single Channel Source Separation
using Short-time Independent Component
Analysis, AES 119th conference, October

M.Every, Discriminating Between Pitched
Sources in Music Audio, IEEE
Transactions, Feb 2008

S.Hainsworth and M.Macleod.
Onset detection in musical audio signals.
In Proc. Int. Computer Music Conference,
pages 163–6, 2003

JP Bello, L Daudet, S Abdallah, C
Duxbury, M Davies, M Sandler, A Tutorial
on Onset Detection in Music Signals. IEEE
Transactions on Speech and Audio
Processing. 13, 1035–1047, Sept. 2005

N.Collins, A Comparison of Sound Onset
Detection Algorithms with Emphasis on
Psychoacoustically Motivated Detection
Functions, AES Convention Paper
Presented at the 118th Convention 2005
May 28–31 Barcelona, Spain

Fenton, S., Fazenda, B. and Wakefield,
J.‘Objective quality measurement of audio
using multiband dynamic range analysis’.
Institute of Acoustics (IOA) Conference-
November 2009

Fenton, S., Wakefield, J. and Fazenda, B.
‘Objective Measurement of Music Quality
Using Inter-Band Relationship
Analysis’.AES 130th Conference, London,
UK., 13th-16th May 2011.

M.Lagrange, M.Raspaud, R.Badeau, and
G.Richard, Explicit Modeling of Temporal
Dynamics within Musical Signals for
Acoustical Unit Similarity, June 2009

Depositing User: Steven Fenton
Date Deposited: 05 Jul 2012 10:26
Last Modified: 03 Dec 2017 06:20


Downloads per month over past year

Repository Staff Only: item control page

View Item View Item

University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©