Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

Crime on public transport. Static and non-static (moving) crime events

Newton, Andrew D. (2004) Crime on public transport. Static and non-static (moving) crime events. Western Criminology Review, 5 (3). pp. 25-42. ISSN 1096-4886

[img] PDF
Restricted to Registered users only

Download (210kB)


    This paper presents a theoretical discussion conceptualising some of the problems evident in analysing patterns of
    crime and disorder on public transport, and the environments within which such crimes occur. The public transport
    system is a multifaceted arena, with a complex interaction of settings (buses, trains and trams), facilities (stops,
    stations and interchanges) and users (staff and passengers). The design of these facilities, and the internal (inside a
    vehicle) and external (that a vehicle traverses) environments may all influence the level of crime experienced on the
    system. Thus, examining the manifestation of crime on public transport systems becomes a highly complex process.
    Current methods of crime analysis focus on ‘static’ crime events with a precise location (x,y co-ordinate). However
    on public transport crime may occur on a moving vehicle (non-static), and it is difficult to define a single location
    for this. For the purposes of analysis, it is contended that non-static crimes have a location, between two points and
    two times, represented as a single snapshot of time. Thus, in addition to analysing static crime events (points and
    areas), attention should also be focussed on how to analyse non-static (linear) crime events. Two possible
    techniques for such analysis are presented, alongside a discussion of the difficulties in collecting accurate and
    consistent data on crime on public transport. It is anticipated that an increase in the availability of such data will
    enable future empirical testing of the ideas presented.

    Item Type: Article
    Additional Information: UoA 40 (Social Work and Social Policy and Administration) ©2004, The Western Criminology Review.
    Subjects: H Social Sciences > HN Social history and conditions. Social problems. Social reform
    H Social Sciences > H Social Sciences (General)
    H Social Sciences > HM Sociology
    Schools: School of Human and Health Sciences
    School of Human and Health Sciences > Applied Criminology Centre
    Related URLs:

    Anselin, L., J. Cohen, D. Cook, W. Gorr, and G. Tita,
    2000, “Spatial Analysis of Crime.” In Criminal Justice
    2000. Measurement and Analysis of Crime and Justice,
    edited by J. Reno, D. Marcus, M. Leary, and J. Samuels [Online].Available:
    html. Accessed 12/02/2002.
    Baker, J, and I. Bewick, 2001. Personal Security on
    Public Transport. Final Report Prepared for
    Merseytravel. Bristol, UK: Transport and Travel
    Research Ltd.
    Belanger, M., 1997. “Crime Trips in the NYC Subway.”
    Transit Policing: 7(2) 15-22.
    Benjamin, J., D. Hartgen, T. Owens, and M. Hardiman.
    1994. “Perception and Incidence of Crime on Public
    Transit in Small Systems in the Southeast.”
    Transportation Research Record 1433:195-200.
    Block, R. and S. Davis. 1996. “The Environs of a Rapid
    Transit Station: A Focus for Street Crime or Just
    Another Risky Place”. Pp. 237-257 in Preventing Mass
    Transit Crime. Crime Prevention Studies Vol. 6, edited
    by R. Clarke. Monsey, NY: Willow Tree Press.
    Bottoms, A. and P. Wiles. 1997. “Environmental
    Criminology.” Pp. 305-349 in The Oxford Handbook of
    Criminology, edited by M. Maguire, R. Morgan, and R.
    Reiner. Oxford, UK: Clarendon Press.
    Brantigham, P. and P. Brantingham. 1981.
    Environmental Criminology. Beverly Hills, Ca: Sage
    Brantigham, P. and P. Brantingham. 1993.
    “Environment, Routine and Situation. Toward a Pattern
    Theory of Crime.” Pp. 259-294 in Routine Activity and
    Rational Choice: Advances in Criminological Theory
    Volume 5, edited by R. Clarke and M. Felson. New
    Jersey: Transaction Publishers.
    Brantigham, P. and P. Brantingham. 1995. “Criminality
    of Place: Crime Generators and Crime Attractors.”
    European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research:
    3(3) 5-26.
    Brown, P. 1991. “Exploring Geodemographics.” Pp
    221-258 in Handling Geographic Information:
    Methodology and Potential Applications, edited by I.
    Masser and M. Blakemore. London: Longman.
    Budd, T. 1999. “Violence at Work: Findings from the
    British Crime Survey.” Home Office Occasional Paper.
    London: Home Office.
    Chainey, S. 2002. Focus Areas and Hot Spots. [Online].
    Accessed 21/09/2002.
    Clarke, R. 1996. Preventing Mass Transit Crime. Crime
    Prevention Studies Vol. 6. Monsey, NY: Willow Tree
    Clarke, R. 1997. Situational Crime Prevention:
    Successful Case Studies. Second Edition. New York:
    Harrow and Heston.
    Clarke, R. and J. Eck. 2003. Become a Problem-Solving
    Crime Analyst in 55 Small Steps. Devon, UK: Willan
    Cohen, L. and M. Felson. 1979. Social Change and
    Crime Rate Trends: A Routine Activity Approach.
    American Sociological Review 44: 588-608.
    Cornish, D. and R. Clarke. 1986. The Reasoning
    Criminal. New York: Springer-Verlag.
    Crime Concern. 2000. Reporting and Recording
    Incidents: Bus Related Incidents of Crime and Disorder.
    Unpublished Report. Bristol, UK: Crime Concern.
    Crime Concern. 2004. Understanding the Links
    Between Bus-Related Crime and Other Crime. Analysis
    of Crime and Disorder Audits Strategies, Round 2 –
    2002. London, UK: Department for Transport (DfT).
    DETR (Department of the Environment, Transport and
    the Regions). 1998. A New Deal for Transport. Better
    for Everyone. London, UK: DETR.
    DETR (Department of the Environment, Transport and
    the Regions). 1999. Personal Security Issues in
    Pedestrian Journeys. London, UK: DETR.
    DTLR (Department for Transport, Local Government
    and the Regions). 2002. Get On Board. An Agenda for
    Improving Personal Security in Bus Travel. London,
    UK: DTLR.
    Easteal, P. and P. Wilson. 1991. Preventing Crime on
    Transport. Canberra: Australian Institute of
    Eck, J. 1997. “Preventing Crime at Places”. In
    Preventing Crime: What Works, What Doesn’t, What’s
    Promising, edited by L. Sherman, D. Gottfredson, D.
    MacKenzie, J. Eck, P. Reuter and S. Bushway.
    [Online]. Available:
    Accessed Eck, J. and D. Weisburd. 1995. “Crime Places in Crime
    Theory”. Pp 1-33 in Crime and Place. Crime Prevention
    Studies Vol IV edited by J. Eck and D. Weisburd. New
    York: Criminal Justice Press.
    Felson, M. and R. Clarke. 1998. “Opportunity Makes
    the Thief.” Crime Detection and Prevention Series,
    Paper 98. London, UK: Home Office.
    Felson, M., M. Belanger, G. Bichler, C. Bruzinski, G.
    Campbell, C. Fried, K. Grofik, I. Mazur, A. O’Regan, P.
    Sweeney, A. Ullma and L. Willaims, L. 1996.
    “Redesigning Hell: Preventing Crime and Disorder at
    the Port Authority Bus Terminal.” Pp 5-93 in
    Preventing Mass Transit Crime: Crime Prevention
    Studies Vol. 6, edited by R. Clarke. Monsey, NY:
    Willow Tree Press.
    Gaylord, M.and J. Galliher, 1991. “Riding the
    Underground Dragon: Crime Control and Public Order
    on Hong Kong's Mass Transit Railway.” British Journal
    of Criminology. 31 15-36.
    Getis, A., P. Drummy, J. Gartin, W.Gorr, K. Harries, P.
    Rogerson, D. Stoe and R. Wright, 2000. Geographical
    Information Science and Crime Analysis. [Online].
    stract.htm. Accessed 15/09/2003.
    Goldsmith, V., P. McGuire, T. Mollenkopf, and T.
    Ross, 2000. Analysing Crime Patterns: Frontiers of
    Practice. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
    Hillier, B. and S. Schu, 2000. “Crime and The Urban
    Layout. The Need for Evidence.” Pp. 224-250 in Secure
    Foundations. Key Issues in Crime Prevention, Crime
    Reduction and Community Safety edited by S.
    Ballintyne, K. Pease and V. McLaren. London: Institute
    for Public Policy Research.
    Hirschfield, A. and K. Bowers, 2001. Mapping and
    Analysing Crime Data. Lessons from Research and
    Practice. London: Taylor and Francis
    Home Office, 2004. Crime Reduction Toolkits: Public
    Transport. [Online].
    Accessed 15/01/2004.
    Ingalls, G., T. Hartgen and T. Owens, 1994. “Public
    Fear of Crime and Its Role in Bus Transit Use.”
    Transportation Research Record 1433: 201-211.
    LaVigne, N., 1997. Visibility and Vigilance: Metro’s
    Situational Approach to Preventing Subway Crime.
    Washington DC: National Institute of Justice.
    LeBeau, J., 2002. “The Impact of a Hurricane on
    Routine Activities and on Calls for Police Service:
    Charlotte, North Carolina and Hurricane Hugo.” Crime
    Prevention and Safety, an International Journal. 4 (1):
    Levine, N. and M. Wachs, 1986a. “Bus Crime In Los
    Angeles I – Measuring the Impact.” Transportation
    Research A, 20 (4): 273-284.
    Levine, N. and M. Wachs, 1986b. “Bus Crime In Los
    Angeles II – Victims and Public Impact.”
    Transportation Research A, 20 (4): 285-293.
    Levine, N., M. Wachs, and E. Shirazi, 1986. “Crime at
    Bus Stops. A Study of Environmental Factors.” Journal
    of Architectural and Planning Research 3(4): 339-361.
    Liggett, R., A. Loukaitou-Sideres, and H. Iseki, 2001.
    “Bus Stop-Environment Connection. Do Characteristics
    of the Built Environment Correlate with Bus Stop
    Crime?” Transportation Research Record 1760: 20-27.
    Loukaitou-Sideris, A., 1999. “Hot Spots of Bus Stop
    Crime. The Importance of Environmental Attributes.”
    Journal of the American Planning Association 65 (4):
    Mayhew, P., R. Clarke, A. Sturman and M. Hough,
    1976. “Crime as Opportunity.” Home Office Research
    Studies Number 34. London, UK: HMSO.
    Myre, M., and F. Rosso, 1996. “Designing for Security
    in Meteor: A Projected New Metro Line in Paris”. Pp
    199-216 in Preventing Mass Transit Crime. Crime
    Prevention Studies Vol. 6, edited by R. Clarke. Monsey,
    NY: Willow Tree Press.
    Nelson, K., 1997. Policing Mass Transit: Serving a
    Unique Community. FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin,
    January 1997. Washington DC: FBI Publications.
    Newton, A., 2004a. Crime and Disorder on Buses:
    Towards an Evidence Base for Effective Crime
    Prevention. Unpublished PhD thesis. University of
    Liverpool, UK.
    Newton, A. 2004b. “Routing out the Hot Spots:
    Towards using GIS and Crime-Place Principles to
    Examine Criminal Damage to Bus Shelters. In Spatial
    Data for Evidence Based Policy Making. New Data,
    New Methods. Innovations in GIS 10, edited by S. Wise, and M. Kraglia. London, UK: Taylor and Francis.
    Newton, A. and A. Hirschfield, 2004. Understanding
    the Link Between Bus-Related Crime and Other Crimes.
    Report 3B. Crime Analysis and Mapping; A Report on
    the Four Case Study Areas. London, UK: Department
    for Transport (DfT). Forthcoming.
    Openshaw, S. and P. Taylor, 1981. “The Modifiable
    Unit Areal Problem.” Pp 60-69 in Quantitative
    Geography: A British View, edited by N. Wrigley and R.
    Bennett. London: Routledge.
    Pearlstein, A., and M. Wachs, 1982. “Crime in Public
    Transit Systems: An Environmental Design
    Perspective.” Transportation, 11: 277-297.
    Pease, K., 2001. “What to do about it? Lets turn off our
    minds and GIS”. Pp 225-236 in Mapping and Analysing
    Crime Data. Lessons from Research and Practice,
    edited by A. Hirschfield and K. Bowers. London:
    Taylor and Francis.
    Ratcliffe, J., 2002. “Aoristic Signatures and the
    Temporal Analysis of High Crime Patterns.” Journal of
    Quantitative Criminology. 18 (1): 23-43.
    Smith, M. and R. Clarke, 2000. “Crime and Public
    Transport”. Pp 169-233 in Crime and Justice. A Review
    of the Research. Vol 6, edited by M. Tonry and N.
    Morris. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
    Wiles, P. and A. Costello, 2000. “The Road To
    Nowhere: The Evidence for Travelling Criminals.”
    Home Office Research Study No 207. London, UK:
    Home Office.
    Wilson, J and G. Kelling, 1982. “Broken Windows.”
    The Atlantic Monthly 249 (3): 29-38.
    Wise, S. and R. Haining, 1991. “The Role of Spatial
    Analysis in Geographical Information Systems.” AGI
    Proceedings 1991. London, UK: AGI.

    Depositing User: Sara Taylor
    Date Deposited: 24 Aug 2007
    Last Modified: 28 Jul 2010 19:21


    Downloads per month over past year

    Repository Staff Only: item control page

    View Item

    University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©