Canter, David V., Hammond, Laura, Youngs, Donna E. and Juszczak, Piotr (2013) The Efficacy of Ideographic Models for Geographical Offender Profiling. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 29 (3). pp. 423-446. ISSN 0748-4518

Objectives: Current ‘geographical offender profiling’ methods that predict an offender’s base location from information about where he commits his crimes have been limited by employing aggregate distributions across a number of offenders, ignoring the possibility of axially distorted distributions and working with limited probability models. The efficacy of five ideographic models (derived only from individual crime series) was therefore tested.

Methods: A dataset of 63 burglary series from the UK was analysed using five different ideographic models to make predictions of the likely location of an offenders home/base: (1) a Gaussian-based density analysis (kernel density estimation); (2) a regression-based analysis; (3) an application of the ‘Circle Hypothesis’; (4) a mixed Gaussian method; and (5) a Minimum Spanning Tree (MST) analysis. These tests were carried out by incorporating the models into a new version of the widely utilised Dragnet geographical profiling system DragNetP. The efficacy of the models was determined using both distance and area measures.

Results: Results were compared between the different algorithms and with previously reported findings employing nomothetic algorithms, Bayesian approaches and human judges. Overall the ideographic models performed better than alternate strategies and human judges. Each model was optimal for some series, no one model producing the best results for all series.

Conclusions: Although restricted to one limited sample the current study does show that these offenders vary considerably in the spatial distribution of offence location choice and mathematical models therefore need to take this into account. Such models will improve geographically based investigative decision support systems.

The_Efficacy_of_Ideographic_Models_for_Geographical_Offender_Profiling_(final).pdf - Accepted Version

Download (811kB) | Preview


Downloads per month over past year

Add to AnyAdd to TwitterAdd to FacebookAdd to LinkedinAdd to PinterestAdd to Email