Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

An evaluation of the factors that determine carrier selection

Wong, Peter Chi Chung (2007) An evaluation of the factors that determine carrier selection. Doctoral thesis, University of Huddersfield.

Download (2MB) | Preview


The selection of freight transport mode in cities like Hong Kong, with little land, is in some
respects obvious. The deciding criterion for mode/carrier selection is based on the selection
of either the lowest total transport cost or the shortest transit time for the cargo. The peculiar
nature of each transport mode, namely; rail, sea, road and air, will definitely earn their own
places when shippers need to make a decision on their shipments. The nature of the cargo
will also affect the choice of carrier/mode when they are transported in break bulk.
Fortunately, the invention of ISO containers in the late 1950s eliminated and overcame the
shortfall in some transport modes. With the extensive usage of ISO containers hereafter,
shippers can now enjoy a much freer choice of transport mode.
When China started its open-door policy in the late 1970s, many local (Hong Kong)
manufacturers relocated their factories to the Pearl River Delta (PRD) due to the low labour
and land costs. Delivery of shipments was mainly carried out by Hong Kong freight
forwarders as they had been in business with the shippers for decades. Road transport was the
only mode choice available at that time due to the inflexibilities in other transport modes such
as sea and rail. Progressively, these factories were relocated northwards at a later time due to
the gradually increasing labour and land costs. Freight forwarders were then faced with a
prolonged delivery time due to the stringent Customs regulations in China as well as a
progressive increase in the physical distance between the factory and the loading port in
Hong Kong. The continuous developments in adjacent ports in Southern China offered
freight forwarders an opportunity to revise the route of consignments so that the lowest cost
and shortest transit times were achievable. Nowadays, consignments from the PRD region can be transported to the loading ports via at least three transport modes, namely, sea (barge),
road (truck) and rail.
In addition to physical constraints in the mode/carrier selection, the mode choice in China is
further complicated due to the inflexible Customs regulations and government policies on tax
Considerable research has been done on mode and carrier selection for bulk cargo in Western
countries. However there is no explicit study on the mode choice in China. This thesis studies
factors that will affect the shippers’ mode/carrier choice and ascertains the unique key factors
that will affect their mode/carrier choice in the PRD for their overseas consignments. From
this study, it was observed that shippers irrespective of the consignment size and cargo value
prefer to use a loading port that is reliable and efficienct in operation. This is the first thesis
written about carrier mode choice in China applying systematic and rationale methods to
express the mode selection criteria in PRD area. The results were achieved by using the
pairwise comparison method - Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) method so that rigidity of
the results is academically accepted. Nevertheless, further study on the mode choice can be
carried forward through assessing buying behaviour and the shipper-carrier relationship.

▼ Jump to Download Statistics
Item Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Additional Information: © The Author 2007
Uncontrolled Keywords: Southern China; freight transport; mode/carrier selection
Subjects: H Social Sciences > H Social Sciences (General)
H Social Sciences > HE Transportation and Communications
Schools: School of Applied Sciences

Abshire, R. D. and Premeaux, S. R., (1991), Motor carriers and shippers perceptions of the
carrier choice decision, Transportation Journal, 31(1), 31-35
Anderson, J., Narus, J., (1990). A model of the distributor firm and manufacturer firm
working partnership. Journal of Marketing, 54, 42–58.
Baker, G. H., (1984), The Carrier Elimination Decision-Implications for Motor Carrier
Marketing, Transportation Journal, 24, 20-29
Bardi, E. J., Bagchi, P. K. and Raghunathan, T. S., (1989), Motor Carrier Selection in a
Deregulated Environment, Transportation Journal, 29(1),4-11
Bardi, E., (1973), Carrier Selection from One Mode, Transport Journal, 12(4), 23-29
Baumol, W.J. and vinod, H.D., (1970), An Inventory Theoretic Model of Freight Transport
Demand, Management Science, 16(7), 413-421
Bayliss, B.T. and Edwards, S.L., (1970), Industrial demand for transport, Ministry of
Transport, London
Bleeke, J., Ernst, D., (1991). The way to win in cross-border alliances. Harvard Business
Review, 127–135.
Boone, L.E., Kurtz, D.L., (2001). Contemporary Marketing, 10th ed., Forth Worth, Harcourt
College Publishers, USA.
Bowersox, D.J., Daugherty, P. J., Droge, C. L., Rogers, D. S. and Wardlow, D. L., (1989),
Leading Edge Logistics Competitive Positioning for the 1990’s, The Council of Logistics
Management, Chicago, IL
Brace, I., (2004), Questionnaire design: how to plan, structure, and write survey material for
effective market research, Kogan Page, London
Brand, R.R. and Grabner, J. R., (1985), An examination of the Carrier selection process in a
Deregulated Economy, 23rd Annual Conference Proceedings – Council of Logistics
Management, St Louis, 1, 173-196 Brooks, M.R., (1984), Limitations in the Carrier Choice Process: A Study of Eastern
Canadian Containerisable Cargo, International Journal of Physical Distribution and
Materials Management, 15 (3), 38-46
Brooks, M.R., (1995), Understanding the Ocean Container Market - a Seven Country Study,
Journal of Maritime Policy and Management, 22(1), 39-49
Brown, J.D.,(2000),What issues affect Likert-scale questionnaire formats?, Shiken: JALT
Testing & Evaluation SIG Newsletter, 4 (1), 18-21
Burdg, H. B. and Daley, J.M., (1985), Shallow water transportation: marketing implications
of user and carrier attribute perceptions, Transport Journal, 24(3), 55-67
CCustoms, (2006), information obtained from the website of China Customs Office
(available at )
Chow, G. and Poist, R.F., (1984), The Measurement of Quality of Service and the
Transportation Purchase Decision, The Logistics and Transportation Review, 20(1), 25-43
Cook, W.R., (1967), Transport Decisions of Certain Firms in the Black Country, Journal of
Transport Economics and Policy, 1(3), 325-344
Cooper and Schindler, (1998), Business Research Methods, 6th Edition, McGraw-Hill
International Editions
Coyle, J.J. and Andraski, J. C., (1990), Management Channel Relationships, Annual
Conference Proceedings, The Council of Logistics Management, Oak Brook, IL, 245-257
Coyle, J.J., Bardi, E.J., Novack, R.A., (1999). Transportation, .fifth ed. South-Western
College Publishing, USA.
Craig, T., (1973), A Behavioural Model of Modal Selection, Transportation Journal, 24-25
CSD, (2007), Hong Kong SAR Government Census and Statistics Department, ( available at )
Cudeck,R.,(2000), Exploratory Factor Analysis: In handbook of Applied multivariate
statistics and mathematical modelling, Academic Press, San Diego Cullinane, K. and Kwan, R., (2000), Freight mode choice in Guangdong province,
Department of Shipping and Transport Logistics, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University.
Cunningham, M.T. and Kettlewood, K., (1976), Source Loyalty in the Freight Transport
Market, European Journal of Marketing, 10(1), 60-79
Cunningham, M.T., (1982), International Marketing and Purchasing of Industrial Goods –
Features of a European Research Project, European Journal of Marketing, 14 (5/6), 322-38
Ellram, L.M., Hendrick, T.E., (1995). Partnering characteristics: a dyadic perspective, Journal
of Business Logistics 16(1), 41–64.
Erasmus, A.C., Boshoff, E. & Rousseau, G. (2002). The potential of using script theory in
consumer behaviour research. Journal for Family Ecology and Consumer Sciences , 30, 1-9.
Evans, R. E. and Southard, W. R., (1974), Motor Carriers and Shippers Perceptions of the
Carrier Choice Decision, The Logistics and Transportation Review, 10(2),.145-147
Evers, P.T., Harper, D.V. and Needham, P.M., (1996), The Determinants of Shipper
Perceptions of Modes, Transportation Journal, 36(2), 13-25
Faller, P.,(1985), Changes in Transport users’ motivations for modal choice: Freight
Transport, European Conference of Ministers of Transport, Paris, 7-17
Fang, T., (2001), Culture as a Driving Force for Interfirm Adaptation: A Chinese Case,
Industrial Marketing Management, 30, 51–63
FHK, (2003), Made in PRD study: The Changing Face of Hong Kong Manufacturers,
Federation of Hong Kong
FHK, (2007), Made in PRD study: Challenges and Opportunities for Hong Kong industry,
Federation of Hong Kong
FIC, (2000), The latest directory of foreign investment in China 2000, Beijing : Zhongguo
Hua qiao chu ban she, (北京 : 中國華僑出版社, 2000)
Foster, J. R., and Strasser, S., (1990), Carrier/Modal Selection Factors: The Shipper/Carrier
Paradox, Journal of the Transportation Research Forum, 31(1), 206-208 FTEC, (2007), The Department of Foreign Trade and Economic Cooperation of Guangdong
Province, China. (available at website : )
Ganesan, S., (1994). Determinants of long-term orientation in buyer–seller relationships.
Journal of Marketing, 58, 1–19.
Gardner, J.T., Cooper, M.C., Noordewier, T., (1994). Understanding shipper–carrier and
shipper–warehouse relationships: partnerships revisited. Journal of Business Logistics 15 (2),
Gentry, J., (1991), Purchasing's Involvement in Transportation Decision-Making, Centre for
Advanced Purchasing Studies/National Association of Purchasing Managers, USA
Gilmour, P., (1976), Some policy implications of subjective factors in the modal choice for
freight movements, The logistics and transportation review, 12(1), 39-57
Gray, R. (1982), Behavioral Approaches to Freight Transport Modal Choice, Transport
Reviews 2(2), 161-184
Green, Salkind and Akey, Samuel, B., Neil,J. and Theresa, M., (2000), Using SPSS for
windows: Analysing and Understanding Data, PrenticeHall Inc. USA
GZM meeting, (1980), The category of industrial area was established when Deng Xiaoping
visited Guangzhou on 31-3-1980. The news was reported from various newspapers (available
at )
Hall, P.K., (1992), Service Quality as a Differentiating Feature in Bulk Chemical
Transportation: An Empirical Investigation, Ph.D. dissertation, University of Missouri,
Columbia, USA
HKSAR, (2006), HKSAR Government publication: Cross-boundary Traffic, November 2006.
( available at )
Jerman, R. E., Anderson R. D. and Constantin, J. A., (1978), Shipper versus Carrier
Perceptions, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Marketing Management,
7,60-64 Jerman, R. E., Anderson, R. D. and Constantin, J.A., (1978), Shipper versus carrier
perceptions of carrier selection variables, International Journal of Physical Distribution and
Material Management, 9(1), 29-38
Jones, J.R.,( 1975), Industrial Shipper Survey Plant Level, U. S. Department of
Transportation, Washington D. C.
Juang, YC. And Gray, R. (2002), Modelling intermodal transport systems: A methodology
for inland container traffic, Logistics Research Network Conference 2002, Birmingham.
Kent, J.K. and Parker, R. S., (1999), International containership carrier selection criteria,
International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, 29 (6), 398-408
Kim & Muller, (1978), Factor Analysis: Statistical Methods and Practical Issues, London,
SAGE Publication
Kinoshita, E. and Masatake Nakanishi, (1999), Proposal of New AHP Model in Light of
Dominant Relationship Among Alternatives, Journal of the Operations Research Society of
Japan, 42(2),180-197
Kozak, R.A., (1997). Distributor-supplier partnering relationships: a case in trust. Journal of
Business Research 39, 33–38.
Krapfel, R. E. and Mentzer, J. T., (1982), Shippers Transportation Choice Processes Under
Deregulation, Industrial Marketing Management, 11, 117-124
LaLonde, B. J., (1991), Whatever happened to one-stop transportation shopping, Transport
Topics, 13, 1-4
Lambert, D.M., Lewis, M.C., and Stock, J. R., (1993), How Shippers Select and Evaluate
General Commodities LTL Motor Carriers, Journal of Business Logistics, 14(1), 131-143
Lambert, D.M., Stock, J.R., (1993). Strategic Logistics Management, third ed. Irwin, USA.
Lian L, (2004), China Processing Trade All-in-One Guide ( 中國加工貿易完全手冊 ),
Chinese Manufacturers' Association (CMA), Hong Kong Lirn, T.C., Thanopoulou, H.A.,Beynon, M.J., and Beresford, A.K.C. (2004), An application
of AHP on Transhipment Port Selection: A Global Perspective, Maritime Economics &
Logistics, 6, 70-91
McGinnis, M. A., (1979), Shipper Attitudes Toward Freight Transportation Choice: A Factor
Analytic Study, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Materials Management,
10(1), 31-33
McGinnis, M. A., (1989), A Comparative Evaluation of Freight Transportation Choice
Models, Transportation Journal, 29 (2), 36-41
McGinnis, M. A., (1990), The Relative Importance of Cost and Service in Freight
Transportation Choice: Before and After Deregulation, Transportation Journal, 30 (1), 12-19
McKinnon, A. C., (1989a), Physical Distribution Systems, Routledge, London, 151-178
McKinnon, A. C., (1989b), The Growth of road freight in the UK, International Journal of
Physical Distribution and Materials Management, 19(4)
MD, (2007), Hong Kong SAR Government Marine Department, ( available at
Milligan, B., (1999), Global economic rally puts heat on shippers and carriers, Purchasing
Online, 15 July 1999.
Miminahan, T. (1998), It pays to know your options, Purchasing Online, March 12 1998.
Mohr, J. and Spekman, R., (1994). Characteristics of partnership success: partnership
attributes, communication behavior, and conflict resolution techniques. Strategic
Management Journal 15, 135–152.
Morton, A. L., (1972), Intermodal Competition for Intercity Transport of Manufacturers,
Land Economics, 48(4), 357-366
Murphy, P. R., Daley, J.M. and Hall, P. K., (1997), Carrier Selection: Do Shippers and
Carriers Agree or Not ? The Logistics and Transportation Review, 33 (1), 67-72
Murphy, P. R., Daley, J.M. and Hall, P.K., (1997), Carrier Selection: Do Shippers and
Carriers Agree or Not?, The Logistics and Transportation Review, 33(1),67-72 Murphy, P.R. and Hall, P. K., (1995), The relative importance of cost and service in freight
transportation choice before and after deregulation: an update, Transportation Journal, 35(1),
Murphy, P.R., Daley, J. M. and Dalenberg, D. R., (1991), Selecting Links and Nodes in
International Transportation: An Intermediary’s Perspective, Transportation Journal, 31(2),
Murphy, P.R., Daley, J. M. and Dalenberg, D.R., (1991), Selecting Links and Nodes in
International Transportation: An Intermediary's Perspective, Transportation Journal, 31(2),
NAROS, (2006), North American Representative Office of Shenzhen (available at )
Ortuzar, J. D. and Willumsen, L.G. (1994), Modeling Transport, , John Wiley & Sons,
Pearson, R., (1980), Container line Performance and Service Quality, University of
Liverpool, Marine Transport Centre, Liverpool
Pisharodi, R., (1991), The Transport Choice Decision Process: The Potential Methodology
and Applications of Script-theoretic Modelling, International Journal of Physical
Distribution and Logistics Management, 21(5), 13-22
Porter, M.E., (1980). Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and
Competitors. Free Press, New York.
Powell, W., (1987), Hybrid organizational arrangements: new form or transitional
development, California Management Review, 30 (1), 67–87.
Quinn, F.J., (1987), How Shippers Choose a Motor Carrier, Traffic Management, 26(11), 43-
Roberts, P.,(1971), The Logistics Management Process as a model of Freight Traffic Demand,
PTRC, “Freight Traffic Models” Symposium
Saaty T L., (1994a) Highlights and critical points in the theory and application of the
Analytic Hierarchy Process, European Journal of Operational Research, 74(3,5), 426-447 Saaty T. L., and Vargas, L. G. (1997), Implementing neural firing: towards a new technology,
Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 26(4), 113-124.
Saaty T. L.,(1994b), Homogeneity and clustering in AHP ensures the validity of the scale,
European Journal of Operational Research, 72( 3), 598-601
Saaty, T. L and Vargas, L. G. (1997), Implementing neural firing: Towards a new technology,
Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 26( 4), 113-124.
Saaty, T. L. and Hu, G (1998), Ranking by Eigenvector versus other methods in the Analytic
Hierarchy Process, Applied Mathematics Letters, 11( 4), 121-125
Saaty, T. L., (1987), New macroeconomic forecasting and policy evaluation method using the
analytic hierarchy process, Mathematical Modeling, 9( 3-5), 219-231
Saaty, T.,(1983), The Analytic Hierarchy Process, McGraw-Hill, New York
Saleh, F. A. and Das, C., (1974), Transport Service Choice, International Journal of Physical
Distribution, 4(5),297-304
Saleh, F. and La Londe, B. J., (1972), Industrial Behaviour and the Motor Carrier Selection
Decision, Journal of Purchasing, 8(1), 18-33
Schurr, P. H., Stone, H. and Beller, L (1985) Effective selling approaches to buyers'
objections , Industrial Marketing Management, 14(3), 195-202
SCT, (2007), Shekou Container Terminals, Hong Kong (available at )
Sharp, C.,(1970), The Allocation of Freight Traffic, Ministry of Transport, London, 1970
Sharp, C.,(1971), The Optimum Allocation of Freight Traffic, Journal of Transport,
Economics and Policy, 5(3), 344-356
Sheffi, Y., Eskandari, B. and Koutsopoulos, H. N., (1988), Transportation Mode Choice
Based on Total Logistics Costs, Journal of Business Logistics, 9(2), 143-150
Simchi-Levi, D., Kaminsky, P. and Simchi-Levi, E., (2000), Designing and Managing the
Supply Chain – concepts, strategies and case studies, McGraw-Hill, U.S.A. Slater A., (1990), Choice of the transport mode, The Gower Handbook of Logistics and
Distribution Management, GATTORNA, J., Gower, Aldershot,.314-339.
Song, D. W. and Yeo, K. T. (2004), A competitive Analysis of Chinese Container Ports using
the analytic Hierarchy Process, Maritime Economics & Logistics, 6, 34-52
Stock, J. R. and Lambert, D. M. (1992) Becoming a “world” class company with logistics
service quality, The International Journal of Logistics Management 3 (1), 73-81
Stock, J. R., and La Londe, B. J., (1978), The purchasing approach to Transportation Mode
Selection, Journal of Purchasing and Materials Management, 3-7
Traffic Management, (1966), How Do You Choose A Carrier?, November, 70-72
Tyworth, J. E., and Zeng, A. Z., (1998), Estimating the effects of carrier transit-time
performance on logistics cost and service, Transportation Research – A, 32( 2), 89-97
Ugboma, C., Ugboma, O. and Ogwude,I. (2006), An analytic Hierarchy Process Approach to
port selection Decisions – Empirical Evidence from Nigerian Ports, Maritime Economics &
Logistics, 8, 251-266
Vlosky, R.P., Wilson, E.J., (1997). Partnering and traditional relationships in business
marketing: an introduction to the special issue. Journal of Business Research 39, 1–4.
Watson, P. L., Hartweg, J. C. and Linton, W.E., (1974), Factors Influencing Shipping Mode
for Intercity Freight: A Disaggregate Approach Proceedings, 15th Annual Meeting, American
Transportation Research Forum, Oxford, Indiana, pp.138-144
Whiteing, T. & Stantchev, D. (2004), Freight Transport and Logistics in the Yorkshire and
Humber Region: Addressing the Skills Gaps, UTSG, Newcastle Upon Tyr

Depositing User: Sara Taylor
Date Deposited: 02 May 2008 14:18
Last Modified: 30 Nov 2016 17:42


Downloads per month over past year

Repository Staff Only: item control page

View Item View Item

University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©