Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

Environmental management and auditing systems: the reality of environmental self-regulation

Watson, Michael and Emery, A.R.T. (2004) Environmental management and auditing systems: the reality of environmental self-regulation. Managerial auditing journal, 19 (7). pp. 916-928. ISSN 0268-6902

[img] PDF
Restricted to Registered users only

Download (83kB)


This paper surveys the evidence that environmental auditing systems (EMSs), and the standard setting bodies represented by ISO 14001 and EMAS, have failed to meet their objectives on two counts. First, the standards will not lead to sustainability and second, they will not be any more economically efficient than the command and control approach. We begin by offering an historical overview of environmental standards and argue that the original intentions to link the environmental management standards with sustainability was abandoned during discussions. The opposing viewpoints about ISO 14001 and EMAS as market driven standards are discussed and then the degree of market penetration of the standards is examined. The costs of implementing an EMS are discussed in the context of the Swiss experience, and the costs to SMEs of EMSs outlined. Practical difficulties associated with the standards are considered, and the question asked, “Do EMSs lead to environmental improvement?‿

Item Type: Article
Additional Information: Copyright © Emerald Group Publishing Limited
Uncontrolled Keywords: Law; Environmental regulations; Auditing; Sustainable development
Subjects: G Geography. Anthropology. Recreation > GE Environmental Sciences
H Social Sciences > HF Commerce > HF5601 Accounting
H Social Sciences > HJ Public Finance
Schools: Huddersfield Business School
References: Ackerman, B.A., Stewart, R.B. (1985), "Reforming environmental law", Stanford Law Review, Vol. 37 pp.1333-65. Biondi, V., Frey, M., Iraldo, F. (2000), "Environmental management systems and SMEs: motivations, opportunities and barriers related to EMAs and ISO 14001 implementation", Greener Management International, No.29, pp.55-69. De Prez, P. (2000), "Beyond judicial sanctions: the negative impact of conviction for environmental offences", Environmental Law Review, Vol. 2 No.1, pp.11-22. Emery, A.R.T. (2002), "The challenge of environmental accounting", Journal of the Economics and Business Education Association, Vol. 6 No.3, pp.13-20. ENDS (2003a), "Regulators place EMS auditors under the magnifying glass", Report 342, pp. 20-3, Environmental Data Services, London, . ENDS (2003b), "EMS survey reveals widespread concerns over certification", Report 347, pp. 19-21, Environmental Data Services, London, . Environmental Manager (1996), "ISO 14001: a critical view", Vol. 7 No.3, pp.13-15. Fineman, S. (2000), "Enforcing the environment: regulatory realities", Business Strategy and the Environment, Vol. 9 pp.62-72. Flynn, B. (2003), "Much talk but little action? ‘New’ environmental policy instruments in Ireland", Environmental Politics, Vol. 12 No.1, pp.137-56. Fortes, H. (2003), "The need for environmental reporting by companies: an examination of the use of environmental reports by Swedish public companies", Greener Management International, No.40, pp.77-92. Freimann, J., Walther, M. (2001), "The impacts of corporate environmental management systems: a comparison of EMAS and ISO 14001", Greener Management International, No.36, pp.91-103. Getimis, P., Giannakourou, G. (2001), "The development of environmental policy in Greece", in Heinelt, H., Malek, T., Smith, R., Toller, A.E. (Eds),European Union Environmental Policy and New Forms of Governance, Ashgate, Aldershot, pp.289-94. Giannakourou, G. (2001), "The implementation of EMAS (and ISO 14001) in Greece", in Heinelt, H., Malek, T., Smith, R., Toller, A.E. (Eds),European Union Environmental Policy and New Forms of Governance, Ashgate, Aldershot, pp.335-40. Gray, R., Bebbington, J. (2001), Accounting for the Environment, Sage Publications, London, . Hamschmidt, J., Dyllick, T. (2001), "ISO 14001: profitable? Yes! but is it eco-effective?", Greener Management International, No.36, pp.43-54. Hillary, R. (1998), "Pan-European Union assessment of EMAS implementation", European Environment, Vol. 8 pp.184-92. Howell, C., Pontin, B. (2003), "The environmental dimension to company law modernisation", Environmental Law and Management, Vol. 15 No.6, pp.354-66. Hussen, A.M. (1999), Principles of Environmental Economics: Ecology, Economics and Public Policy, Routledge, London, . ISO (2003), Survey of ISO 9000 and 14001 certificates, available at:, . Jordan, A., Wurzel, R.K.W., Zito, A.R. (2003), "‘New’ instruments of environmental governance: patterns and pathways of change", Environmental Politics, Vol. 12 No.1, pp.3-24. Kollman, K., Prakash, A. (2002), "EMS-based environmental regimes as club goods: examining variations in firm-level adoption of ISO 14001 and EMAS in UK, US and Germany", Policy Sciences, Vol. 35 pp.43-67. Kreuze, J.G., Newell, G.E. (1994), "ABC and life-cycle costing for environmental expenditure", Management Accounting, pp.38-42. Krut, R., Gleckman, H. (1998), ISO 14001 A Missed Opportunity for Global Sustainable Development, Earthscan Publications, London, . MacLean, R. (February, 2004), "Environmental management systems: do they provide real business value?", Environmental Protection, pp.12-14. Malek, T. (2001), "The development of environmental policy in germany", in Heinelt, H., Malek, T., Smith, R., Toller, A.E. (Eds),Ashgate, Aldershot, European Union Environmental Policy and New Forms of Governance, pp.56-60. Orts, E.W. (1995), "Reflexive environmental law", Northwestern University Law Review, Vol. 89 No.4, pp.1227-340. Roht-Arriaza, N. (2002), "The international organization for standardization: drafting of the ISO 14000 Series", in Steinberg, R.H. (Eds),The Greening of Trade Law: International Trade Organizations and Environmental Issues, Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, New York, NY, . Staffin, E. (1996), "Trade barrier or trade boon? A critical evaluation of eco-labelling and its role in the Greening of world trade", Columbia Journal of Environmental Law, Vol. 21 pp.205-86. Steinzor, R.I. (1998), "Reinventing environmental regulation: the dangerous journey from command to self-control", Harvard Environmental Law Review, Vol. 22 pp.103-202. Watson, M. (2002), "Sentencing the environmental offender", Justice of the Peace, Vol. 166 pp.924-6. Watson, M. (2003), "Low fines for environmental offences? Blame the regulators not the courts", Vol. 167 pp.50-2. Watson, M., Emery, A.R.T. (n.d.), "Law, economics and the environment: a comparative study of environmental management systems", Managerial Auditing Journal, (forthcoming), . Wells, R.P., Galbraith, D. (1999), "Proyecto Guadalajara: promoting sustainable development through the adoption of ISO 14001 by small and medium sized enterprises", Greener Management International, Vol. 28 pp.90-102. Wolf, S., Stanley, N. (2003), Wolf and Stanley on Environmental Law, Cavendish, London, . World Bank (2003), Data and Statistics, available at:, . World Commission on Environment and Development (1987), Our Common Future, Oxford University Press, New York, NY, . Wurzel, R.K.W., Jordan, A., Zito, A.R., Bruckner, L. (2003a), "Struggling to leave behind a highly regulatory past? ‘New’ environmental policy instruments in Austria", Environmental Politics, Vol. 12 No.1, pp.51-72. Wurzel, R.K.W., Jordan, A., Zito, A.R., Bruckner, L. (2003b), "From high regulatory state to social and ecological market economy? ‘New’ environmental policy instruments in Germany", Environmental Politics, Vol. 12 No.1, pp.115-36.
Depositing User: Sara Taylor
Date Deposited: 01 Mar 2007
Last Modified: 28 Aug 2021 23:36


Downloads per month over past year

Repository Staff Only: item control page

View Item View Item

University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©