Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

Strange Attractors: A Commentary on Applications of Indeterminacy in my Recent Music

McLaughlin, Scott (2009) Strange Attractors: A Commentary on Applications of Indeterminacy in my Recent Music. Doctoral thesis, University of Huddersfield.

[img] PDF (PhD composition commentary) - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial.

Download (1MB)


This commentary reflects on how indeterminacy has been used in the music I have written over the period of my doctoral studies, 2005-2008. Non-musical ideas play a major role in my compositional language and this is reflected in the use of 'strange attractors' as a metaphor for the philosophical and aesthetic stance behind composing with indeterminacy. After a brief introduction chapter, the links between strange attractors—and chaos theory in general—and indeterminate music are discussed. And applications of indeterminacy to pitch organisation techniques such as spectral modelling and frequency modulation are examined as part of a frequency-based harmonic continuum. Different methods of generating ambiguous pitch percepts that sit at the boundaries of the harmony/timbre duality are considered In pieces with text processes.

▼ Jump to Download Statistics
Item Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Uncontrolled Keywords: spectral, indeterminacy, multiphonic, composition, strange attractor.
Subjects: M Music and Books on Music > M Music
Schools: School of Music, Humanities and Media
Related URLs:
References: Anderson, Martin, 'The Many Patterns of Per Nørgård', Tempo, New Series, No. 202 (Oct., 1997), pp. 3-7. Attali, Jacques, Noise: The Political Economy of Music (Minneapolis, 1985). Barlow, Clarence, Im Januar am nil (Cologne, 1984) Barrett, G. Douglas, Surfaces I-IV, self published (Buffalo, 2007). Bartolozzi, Bruno, Brindle, Reginald Smith, New Sounds for Woodwind, 2nd edn. (London, 1982). Berio, Luciano, Sequenza no.1 (Milan, 1958). Bodman Rae, Charles, The Music of Lutosławski (London, 1994). Boulez, Pierre, 3rd Piano Sonata (Paris, 1963). Buchanan, Mark, 'Quantum randomness may not be random', New Scientist, No.2468, 22 March 2008. Burraston, D., Edmonds, E., 'Cellular Automata in Generative Electronic Music and Sonic Art: A Historical and Technical Review', Digital Creativity 16/3, (2005), 165-185. Butler, Christopher, Postmodernism: A Very Short Introduction (Oxford, 2002). Cage, John, Atlas Eclipticalis (New York, 1963 ). ________ , Silence (London, 1978). Carter, Elliott, String Quartet no.3 (New York, 1973). Cross, Jonathan, The Stravinsky Legacy (Cambridge, 1998). Deleuze, Gilles, Difference and Repetition (London, 2004). DeLio, Thomas, Circumscribing the Open Universe (London, 1984). Deutsch, D., Kuyper, W. L. and Fisher, Y. 'The tritone paradox: Its presence and form of distribution in a general population', Music Perception, 5, (1987), 79-92. Eco Umberto, The Open Work (Cambridge MA, 1989). Feldman, Morton, Give my Regards to Eighth Street, ed. B.H. Friedman (Cambridge MA, 2000). 124 _____________ , Piano and String Quartet (London, 1985). _____________ , Triadic Memories (London, 1981). _____________ , Morton Feldman Says, ed. Chris Villars (London, 2006). _____________ , Violin and Orchestra (London, 1979). Fox, Christopher, Generic Compositions (Fox Edition, 1989-93). Gleick, James, Chaos: Making a New Science, (London, 1987). Grisey, Gérard, 'Did you say Spectral?', trans. Fineberg, Joshua, Contemporary Music Review, 19/3, (January 2000), 2-4. __________ , Partiels (Paris, 1975). __________ , Modulations (Paris, 1978). Harley, James, Xenakis: His Life and Music (London, 2004). Harvey, Jonathan, The Music of Stockhausen (London, 1975). Hayles, Katherine, 'Chance Operations: Cagean Paradox and Contemporary Science', in John Cage: Composed in America, eds. Perloff, Marjorie and Junkermann, Charles, (London, 1994), 226-241. Jarveläinen, H., Verma, T. and Välimäki, V., 'Perception and adjustment of pitch in inharmonic string instrument tones', Journal of New Music Research. 31/4, (Dec. 2002), 311–319. Johnson, Stephen, The New York Schools of Music and Visual Arts, (London, 2002). Kagel, Mauricio, Match for three Players (Vienna, 1964). Kramer, Lawrence, 'New Temporalities in Music', Critical Inquiry, 7/3, (Spring 1981), 539-556. Kostelanetz, Richard, ed., Conversing with Cage (New (York, 1988). Ligeti, Győrgy, Concerto for Piano and Orchestra (Mainz, 1988). __________ , Concerto for Violin and Orchestra (Mainz, 1992). __________ , Hamburg Concerto (Mainz, 1999). __________ , Ligeti in Conversation (London, 1983). __________ , Piano Etudes (London, 1986). __________ , Piano Etudes: Book II (London, 1994). 125 __________ , Ramifications (London, 1969). __________ , Trio: for Violin Horn and Piano (Mainz, 1982). __________ , Two Studies for Organ (London, 1962). __________ , Volumina (London, 1966). Lucier, Alvin, I am Sitting in a Room (Boston, 1970) __________ , In Memoriam John Higgins (Newport Beach CA, 1987). __________ , 'Origins of a Form: Acoustical Exploration, Science and Incessancy' Leonardo Music Journal, vol. 8, Ghosts and Monsters: Technology and Personality in Contemporary Music (1998), 5-11. __________ , (transcribed by Anne Guthrie.), Ostrava Days 2005 Report (Ostrava, 2006). __________ , Reflections (Cologne, 1995). Lutosławski, Witold, Concerto for Cello and Orchestra (London, 1971). ______________ , Chain 2 for Violin and Orchestra (London, 1988). ______________ , Jeux Vénitiens (Paris, 1962). ______________ , Preludes and Fugue: for 13 Solo Strings (London, 1973). Maconie, Robin, Stockhausen (London, 1976). Matossian, Nouritza, Xenakis (London, 1990). Murail, Tristan, 'After-Thoughts', Contemporary Music Review, 19/3 (January 2000), 5-9. ___________ , Gondwana, (Paris, 1980). ___________ , Le Partage des Eaux, (Paris, 1996). Nagao, Natsuki, 'A Neural Chaos Model of Multistable Perception', Neural Processing Letters 12/3 (December 2000), 267-276. Niblock, Phill, (transcribed by Anne Guthrie.), Ostrava Days 2005 Report (Ostrava, 2006). Nono, Luigi, Fragmente-stille, an Diotima: per Quartetto d'Archi (Milan, 1980). ___________ , 'Hay Que Caminar' Soñando (Milan, 1989). Owen Thomas, Janet, 'Ligeti's Organ Music', The Musical Times, vol. 124, No. 1683 (May, 1983), 319-321. 126 Parsons, Michael, Independent Pulses (London, 1992). Petersen, Peter, 'Microtones in Lutoslawski's Music' Lutoslawski Studies, ed. Skowron, Zbigniew, (Oxford, 2001), 339-353. Pinker, Steven, How the Mind Works (London, 1997). Pratchett, Terry, Hogfather (London, 1996). Radice, Thomas, 'Clarity and Survival in the Zhuangzi', Asian Philosophy, 11/1, (2001), 33-40. Rehfeldt, Phillip, New Directions for Clarinet (London, 1977) Rich, Alan, San Francisco Contemporary Music Players, Mosko, Stephen (Musical Dir.), For Samuel Beckett (sleevenotes), (1991) Newport Classics NPD 85506. Rossing, Thomas D., Moore, F. Richard, Wheeler, Paul A., The Science of Sound, 3rd edn. (San Francisco, 2002). Saunders, James, #[untitled], (Huddersfield, 2000). _____________ , Developing a Modular Approach to Music, (PhD Thesis, University of Huddersfield, 2003). Scavone, Gary Paul, 'An Acoustic Analysis of Single-Reed Woodwind Instruments with an Emphasis on Design and Performance Issues and Digital Waveguide Modeling Techniques', (PhD Dissertation, Stanford University, 1997). Shepard, Roger, 'Cognitive Psychology and Music', Music, Cognition and Computerised Sound: An Introduction to Psychoacoustics ed. Cook, Perry R. (London, 1999), 32-33. Schneider, Peter, 'How Not to Teach Architectural History', Journal of Architectural Education, 34/1, (Autumn, 1980), 23-24. Steinitz, Richard, Gyorgy Ligeti: Music of the Imagination, (London, 2003). ___________ , 'Music, Maths & Chaos', The Musical Times, vol. 137, No. 1837 (March, 1996), pp. 14-20. ___________ , 'The Dynamics of Disorder', The Musical Times, vol. 137, No. 1839 (May, 1996), 7-14. Stockhausen, Karlheinz, Klavierstück XI (London,1956). ___________ , Stimmung (London, 1968). 127 ___________ , Ylem (Kürten, 1972). Stucky, Steven, Lutosławki and his Music, (Cambridge, 1981). Tenney, James, Beast, (Baltimore MD, 1971). ___________ , Arbor Vitae, (Lebanon NH, 2006). ___________ , Meta + Hodos and META Meta + Hodos, 2nd ed. (no place, 1988). Thomas, Philip, 'A prescription for action: a common approach to performing simple, complex, graphic and verbal scores '[lowercase by author], Ashgate Research Companion to Experimental Music, ed. James Saunders, (unpublished draft, 2008). Thompson, D'Arcy Wentworth, On Growth and Form, abridged version, abridged ed. John Tyler Bonner, (London, 1961). Ustvolskaya, Galina, Composition No.2: Dies Irae (Hamburg, 1973). Wannamaker, Robert A., 'The spectral music of James Tenney', Contemporary Music Review, 27/1, (February 2008), 91-130. Waldrop, M. Mitchell, Complexity: The Emerging Science at the Edge of Order and Chaos, (London, 1992). Werder, Manfred, 2 ausführende (Haan, 1999). Winter, Michael, 'On James Tenney's Arbor Vitae for string quartet', Contemporary Music Review, 27/1, (February 2008), 131-150. Witt, Ulrich, 'Generic features of evolution and its continuity: A transdisciplinary perspective', Theoria, 48/18, (2003), 273-288. Wolfram, Stephen, 'Cellular Automata', Los Alamos Science, 9 (Fall 1983), 2-21. Xenakis, Iannis, Duel, (London, 1959). ___________ , Iannis Xenakis: The Man and his Music : A Conversation with the Composer and a Description of his Works, (London, 1967). ___________ , Stratégie, (London, 1962). No author, Blocks of Consciousness, eds. Mark Wastell, Brian Marley (London, 2005). No author, 'Phenotype', Compact Oxford English Dictionary, Eds. Catherine Soames, and Sara Hawker, 3rd ed. (Oxford, 2005). 128 Anderson, Julian, 'Spectral Music', Grove Music Online, ed. Laura Macy, Accessed 07/08/08. Barrett, G. Douglas, 'Bio', <>, accessed 06/08/08. Cody, Joshua, 'The Ensemble Sospeso - Tristan Murail', <>, accessed 07/08/08. Hilgevoord, Jan and Jos Uffink, "The Uncertainty Principle", The Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy (Fall 2006 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), <http://>,accessed 02/08/08. Johnson, Tom, 'I Want to Find the Music, Not to Compose it', (no date), <>, accessed 01/06/08. Maher, Ciarán, 'Spectral Variations by James Tenney, <>, (No date), accessed 21/11/08. Ox, Jack, 'Im Januar am Nil stillshots and animations', <>, (No date), accessed 07/08/08. Pritchett, James, 'Cage, John', Grove Music Online. Oxford Music Online. <>, accessed 05/08/08. Rockwell, John, 'Morton Feldman (and Crippled Symmetry)', Morton Feldman Page, < > accessed 11/12/08 Sani, Frank, 'Why Patterns? An Analysis of Morton Feldman's “Piano and String Quartet”', (2000),>, accessed 13/08/08. Wallin, Rolf, 'Fractal Music: Red Herring or Promised Land', (n.p., 1989), <>, accessed 04/08/08. Weisstein, Eric W., 'Lorenz Attractor', MathWorld--A Wolfram Web Resource, < > accessed 04/08/08. _____________ , 'Mandelbrot Set', MathWorld--A Wolfram Web Resource, <http://>, accessed 04/08/08. 129 _____________ , 'Topology', MathWorld--A Wolfram Web Resource. <>, accessed 07/08/08. Winter, Michael, On Sonification <> (n.p, 2005), (accessed 04/01/07)
Depositing User: Scott Mclaughlin
Date Deposited: 04 Sep 2012 13:47
Last Modified: 28 Aug 2021 20:33


Downloads per month over past year

Repository Staff Only: item control page

View Item View Item

University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©