Search:
Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

The Parliamentary Conservative Party: The leadership elections of William Hague and Iain Duncan Smith

Hill, Michael (2007) The Parliamentary Conservative Party: The leadership elections of William Hague and Iain Duncan Smith. Doctoral thesis, University of Huddersfield.

[img]
Preview
PDF
michaelhillfinalthesis.pdf

Download (1MB) | Preview

Abstract

The aim of this research is to investigate the post1997 Parliamentary Conservative Party, with
particular attention placed upon the Conservative Party leadership election of 1997 and 2001.
The thesis uses these two leadership elections as a lens which can be utilised to focus upon and
analyse the ideological disputations of contemporary British Conservatism. This is done by
identifying the voting behaviour of Conservative parliamentarians in the two leadership elections
and then by putting forwards a systemic explanation of the candidates’ support. Three sets of
variables are tested. First, the thesis analyses socio-economic variables (i.e. the occupational and
educational background of conservative parliamentarians). Second, the research considers the
candidates’ support in relation to electoral and political variables (i.e. electoral vulnerability,
political insider / outsider status, age and experience). Finally the research will evaluate the
candidates’ support with regard to the ideological disposition of the candidates and their
supporters. This requires an extensive exploration of the attitudes of Conservative
parliamentarians with regard to the dominant ideological divides within contemporary post-
Thatcherite Conservatism – economic policy (wet / dry), European policy (europhile /
eurosceptic), and social, sexual and moral attitudes (social liberalism / social conservatism). By
analysing the patterns of voting in relation to social background, political attributes and
ideological disposition the thesis locates and interprets the differing motivational influences on
voting behaviour.
The thesis argues the ideological disposition of the candidates and their supporters was the
crucial factor in both the leadership elections. The final round of the 1997 leadership election
was a straight ideological battle between the europhile and eurosceptic wings of the
parliamentary Conservative Party. This benefited the eurosceptic William Hague at the expense
of the europhile Kenneth Clarke. In 2001 both Clarke and Portillo attracted support from across
the ideological spectrum of the parliamentary party, suggesting that a section of the
parliamentary party had moved away from ideologically driven voting behaviour. However, Iain
Duncan Smith reaching the final ballot was due to the support of an ideologically cohesive group
of traditional Thatcherite MPs and indicative of the continued significance of ideology on the
direction of the Conservative party.

▼ Jump to Download Statistics
Item Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Additional Information: © The Author 2007
Uncontrolled Keywords: Parliamentary Conservative Party leadership elections William Hague Iain Duncan Smith
Subjects: J Political Science > JN Political institutions (Europe) > JN101 Great Britain
J Political Science > JA Political science (General)
Schools: School of Human and Health Sciences
References:

Abbott, P. & Wallace, C. (1990) The Family In: Brown, P. & Sparks, R. (eds.)
Beyond Thatcherism: Social policy, politics and society Buckingham, Open
University Press
Adams, I. (1993) Political Ideology Today Manchester, Manchester University Press
Adonis, A. (1993) Parliament today Manchester, Manchester University Press
Alderman, K. (1998) The Conservative Party Leadership Election of 1997
Parliamentary Affairs Vol. 51, No. 1 pp. 1-16
Alderman, K. (1999) Revision of Leadership Procedures in the Conservative Party
Parliamentary Affairs Vol. 52, No. 2 pp. 260-274
Alderman, K. & Carter, N. (2002) The Conservative Party Leadership Election of
2001 Parliamentary Affairs Vol. 55, No. 3 pp. 569-585
Ancram, M. (21/6/2001) Full text: Michael Ancram declaration
http://politics.guardian.co.uk/conservatives/story/0,,510681,00.html [Accessed
30/8/2005]
Anon. (19/6/1997) How Tory MPs Voted The Daily Telegraph
Anon. (18/6/1997) How Tories lined up behind the three contenders The Times
Baker & Fountain (1996) Eton Gent or Essex Man? The Conservative Parliamentary
Elite In: Ludlam, S. & Smith, M. J. (eds.) Contemporary British Conservatism
London, Macmillan
Baker, D., Gamble, A., & Ludlam, S. (1992) More ‘Classless and Less ‘Thatcherite’?
Conservative Ministers and New Conservative MPs after the 1992 Election
Parliamentary Affairs Vol. 45, No. 4 pp. 656-668
Baker, D., Gamble, A. & Ludlam, S. (1993) 1846…1906…1996? Conservative Splits
and European Integration The Political Quarterly Vol. 64, No. 4 pp. 420-434
Baker, D., Gamble, A. & Ludlam, S. (1994) Mapping Conservative fault lines:
problems of typology In Dunleavy, P. & Stayner, G. (eds.) Contemporary Political
Studies 1994 Exeter, University of Exeter Press
Baker, D. Gamble, A. & Seawright, D. (2002) Sovereign nations and global markets:
modern British Conservatism and hyperglobalism British Journal of Politics and
International Relations Vol. 4, No. 3 pp. 399-428
Baldwin, T. (18/7/01) Portillistas are punished for their arrogance; Tory Leadership
campaign. The Times: page 4 Ball, S. (1995) The Conservative Party and British Politics 1902-1951 London,
Longman
Ball, S. (1996) The National and Regional Party Structure In. Seldon, A. & Ball, S.
(eds.) Conservative Century: The Conservative Party since 1900 Oxford, Oxford
University Press
Ball, S. (1998) The Conservative Party since 1945 Manchester, Manchester
University Press
Barnes, J. (1994) Ideology and Factions In. Seldon, A. & Ball, S. (eds.) Conservative
Century: The Conservative Party since 1900 Oxford, Oxford University Press
Belloff M. & Peele, G. (1980) The Government of the United Kingdom: Political
Authority in a Changing Society London, Weidenfeld & Nicholson
Berrington, H. (1998) Britain in the Nineties: The Politics of Paradox In. Berrington,
H. (ed.) Britain in the Nineties: The Politics of Paradox London, Frank Cass
Berrington, H. & Hague, R. (1998) Europe, Thatcherism and Traditionalism: Opinion,
Rebellion and the Maastricht Treaty in the Backbench Conservative Party, 1992-1994
In. Berrington, H. (ed.) Britain in the Nineties: The Politics of Paradox London,
Frank Cass
Bevins A. & Brown C. (20/6/1997) Tories gamble on their youngest leader since Pitt
The Independent
Bogdanor, V. (1994) The Selection of the Party Leader In. Seldon, A. & Ball, S. (eds.)
Conservative Century: The Conservative Party since 1900 Oxford, Oxford University
Press
Broughton, D. (2004) Doomed to Defeat? Electoral Support and the Conservative
Party The Political Quarterly Vol. 75, No. 4 pp. 350-355
Brown C. (6/5/1997) Runners and riders in race to lead party; Colin Brown runs a
rule over the hopefuls who have thrown their hats in the ring The Independent: page 6
Brown C. (19/6/1997) Thatcher endorses Hague ‘to stop Clarke’ The Independent
Bulpitt, J. (1992) Conservative Leadership and the Euro-Ratchet: Five Doses of
Scepticism Political Quarterly, Vol. 63, No. 3 pp. 258-277
Burch, M. & Moran, M. (1985) The changing British Political Elit, 1945-1983: MPs
and Cabinet Ministers Parliamentary Affairs Vol. 38, No. 1 pp. 1-15
Burke, E. (1991) Edmund Burke In. Scruton, R. (ed.) Conservative Texts: An
Anthology London, Macmillan
Butler, D. & Butler, G. (1994) British Political Facts 1900-1994 London, Macmillan Butler, D. & Kavanagh, D. (1997) The British General Election of 1997 London,
Macmillan
Butler, D. & Kavanagh, D. (2001) The British General Election of 2001 Basingstoke,
Palgrave
Butler, D. & Pinto-Duschinsky, M. (1980) The Conservative Elite, 1918-78: Does
Unrepresentativeness Matter? In Layton-Henry, Z. (ed.) Conservative Party Politics
London, Macmillan
Campbell, J. (2000) Margaret Thatcher. Volume One: The Grocer’s Daughter
London, Jonathan Cape
Campbell, J. (2003) Margaret Thatcher. Volume Two: The Iron Lady London,
Jonathan Cape
Charmley, J. (1996) A History of Conservative Party Politics 1900-1996 Basingstoke
Macmillan
Clark, A. (1998) The Tories: Conservatives and the Nation State 1922-1997 London,
Weidenfeld & Nicholson
Clarke, K. (2001) The Conservatives need a leader who can win the next general
election London, Andrew Tyrie
Clarke, P. (1996) Hope and Glory: Britain 1900-1990 London, Penguin
Coetzee, F. (1990) For Party Or Country: Nationalism and the Dilemmas of Popular
Conservatism in Edwardian England Oxford, Oxford University Press
Coleman, B. (1996) 1841-1846 In: Seldon, A, (ed.) How Tory Governments Fall: the
Tory Party in Power Since 1783 London, Fontana Press
Collings, D. & Seldon, A. (2001) Conservatives in Opposition Parliamentary Affairs
Vol. 54, No. 4, pp. 624-637
Conservative Party (1998) An Introduction to the Conservative Party London,
Conservative Insight
Conservative Party (2000) Believing In Britain London , Conservative Party
Conservative Party (2002) Leadership with a purpose: A Better Society London,
Conservative Party
Cowley, P. (1996) How Did He Do That? The Second Round of the 1990
Conservative Leadership Election In Farrell, D. M., Broughton, D., Denver, D. &
Fisher, J. (eds.) British Election and Parties Yearbook, 1996 London, Frank Cass Cowley, P. & Bailey, M. (2000) Peasants’ Uprising or Religious War? Re-examining
the 1975 Conservative Contest British journal of Political Science Vol. 30, No. 4 pp.
599-629
Cowley, P. & Garry J. (1998) The British Conservative Party and Europe: The
Choosing of John Major British Journal of Political Science Vol. 28, no. 3 pp. 473-
499
Cowley, P. & Norton, P. (1999) Rebels and rebellions: Conservative MPs in the 1992
Parliament The British Journal of Politics & International Relations Vol. 1, No. 1 pp.
84-105
Cowley, P. & Stuart, M. (2003) The Conservative parliamentary party In Garnett, M.
& Lynch, P. (eds.) The Conservatives in crisis Manchester, Manchester University
Press
Coxall, B. & Robins, L. (1998) British Politics Since the War London Macmillan
Crew, I. (1996) 1979-1996 In. Seldon A. (ed.) How Tory Governments Fall: the Tory
Party In Power Since 1783 London, Fontana
Criddle, B. (1994) Members of Parliament In. Seldon, A. & Ball, S. (eds.)
Conservative Century: The Conservative Party since 1900 Oxford, Oxford University
Press
Criddle, B. (1997) MPs and Candidates In. Butler, D. & Kavanagh, D. (1997) The
British General Election of 1997 London, Macmillan
Criddle, B. (2002) MPs and Candidates In. Butler, D. & Kavanagh, D. (1997) The
British General Election of 2001 London, Palgrave
Critchley, J. & Halcrow M. (1998) Collapse of Stout Party: The Decline and Fall of
the Tories London, Indigo
Currie, E. (2002) Diaries: 1987-1992 London, Little, Brown
Davies, A. J. (1995) We, The Nation: The Conservative Party and the Pursuit of
Power London, Little, Brown and Company
Davis, D. (19/6/2001) Full text: statement by David Davis
http://politics.guardian.co.uk/conservatives/story/0,9061,509400,00.html [Accessed
28/8/2005]
Dell, E. (1997) The Chancellors: A History of the Chancellors of the Exchequer,
1945-90 London, Harper Collins
Dod’s Parliamentary Companion 1997 Vacher Dod, London
Dod’s Parliamentary Companion 1998 Vacher Dod, London Dod’s Parliamentary Companion 2002, Vacher Dod, London
Dorey, P. (2003) Conservative policy under Hague In. Garnett, M. & Lynch, P. (eds.)
The Conservatives in crisis Manchester, Manchester University Press
Dorey, P. (2004) Attention to Detail: the Conservative Policy Agenda The Political
Quarterly Vol. 75, No. 4 pp. 373-377
Dunleavy, P. (1993) The Political Parties In. Dunleavy, P., Gamble, A., Holliday, I. &
Peele, G. (eds.) Developments in British Politics 4 London, Macmillan
Dunn, M. & Smith, S. (1990) Economic Policy and Privatisation In. Savage, S. P. &
Robins, L. (eds.) Public Policy under Thatcher London, Macmillan
Durham, M. (1989) The Thatcher Government and the Moral Right Parliamentary
Affairs, Vol. 42, No. 1
Dutton, D. J. (1981) The Unionist Party and Social Policy The Historical Journal,
Vol. 24, No. 4 pp. 871-884
Eccleshall, R. (2002) Conservatism Revisited Politics Review Vol. 11, No. 4 pp. 29-
31
Edgar, D. (1986) The Free or the Good In. Levitas, R. (ed.) The Ideology Of The New
Right London, Polity Press
Evans, B. (1984) Political Ideology and its Role in Recent British Politics
Huddersfield pamphlets in history and politics
Evans, B. & Taylor, A. (1996) From Salisbury to Major: Continuity and change in
Conservative politics Manchester, Manchester University Press
Fisher, N. (1977) The Tory Leaders: their struggle for Power London, Weidenfeld &
Nicholson
Foley, M. (2002) John Major, Tony Blair and a conflict of leadership Manchester,
Manchester University Press
Gamble, A. (1994) The Free Economy and the Strong State: The Politics of
Thatcherism London, Macmillan
Gamble, A. (1996) An Ideological Party In Ludlam, S. & Smith, M., J. (eds.)
Contemporary British Conservatism London, Macmillan
Garnett, M. (2003) Win or bust: the leadership gamble of William Hague In Garnett,
M. & Lynch, P. (eds.) The Conservatives in crisis Manchester, Manchester University
Press Garnett, M. & Lynch, P. (2003) Introduction In Garnett, M. & Lynch, P. (eds.) The
Conservatives in crisis Manchester, Manchester University Press
Garry, J. (1995) The British Conservative Party: Divisions over European Policy
West European Politics Vol. 18, No. 4 pp. 170-189
Geddes, A. (2005) Europe In Hickson, K. (ed.) The Political Thought of the
Conservative Party since 1945 Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan
Geddes, A. & Tonge, J. (1997) Labour’s Landslide Manchester, Manchester
University Press
Gilmour, I. (1977) Inside Right: A Study of Conservatism Quartet
Gilmour, I. (1992) Dancing With Dogma; Britain Under Thatcherism London, simon
& Schuster
Gimour, I. & Garnett, M. (1997) Whatever Happened to the Tories: The
Conservatives since 1945 London, Fourth Estate
Giddens, A. (1995) Beyond Left and Right Cambridge, Polity Press
Gove, M. (1995) Michael Portillo: The Future of the Right London, Fourth Estate
Gray & Willetts (1997) Is Conservatism Dead? London, Profile Books
Green, E. H. H. (2002) Ideologies of Conservatism: Conservative Political Ideas in
the Twentieth Century Oxford, Oxford University Press
Greenwood, J. (1988) Promoting Working-Class Candidature In The Conservative
Party: The Limits of Central Office Power Parliamentary Affairs vol. 41, No. 4 pp.
456-467
Hayes, M. (1994) The New Right in Britain: An Introduction to Theory and Practice
London, Pluto Press.
Hennessy, P. (2000) The Prime Minister: The Office and its Holders since 1945
London, The Penguin Press
Heppell, T. (2002) The ideological composition of the Parliamentary Conservative
Party 1992-97 British Journal of Politics and International Relations Vol. 4 No. 2 pp.
299-324
Heppell, T. & Hill, M. (2005) Ideological Typologies of Contemporary British
Conservatism Political Studies Review Vol. 3 No. 3 pp. 335-355
Heseltine, M. (2001) Life In The Jungle: My Autobiography London, HodderHeywood, A. (1998) Political Ideologies: An Introduction London, Macmillan
Holmes, M. (1998) The Conservative Party and Europe: From Major to Hague The
Political Quarterly Vol. 69, No. 2 pp. 133-139
Ingle, S. (2000) The British Party System London, Pinter
Isaac, J. U. (1990) The New Right and the Moral Society Parliamentary Affairs Vol.
43, No. 2 pp. 209-227
Jenkins, R. (2002) Churchill London, Pan
Kavanagh, D. (1996) 1970-1974 In. Seldon A. (ed.) How Tory Governments Fall: the
Tory Party In Power Since 1783 London, Fontana
Kavanagh, D. (1998) Power in the Parties: R. T. McKenzie and After West European
Politics Vol. 21, No. 1 pp. 28-43
Kavanagh, D. & Seldon, A. (1999) The Powers Behind the Prime Minister: The
Hidden Influence of Number Ten London, Harper Collins
Kavanagh, D. (2005) The Making of Thatcherism: 1974-1979 In. Ball, S. & Seldon A.
(eds.) Recovering Power: The Conservatives in Opposition Since 1867 London,
Palgrave Macmillan
Kelly, R. (1995) Power in the Conservative Party: Developments since 1992 Politics
Review Vol. 4, No. 4 pp. 11-14
Kelly, R. (1999) Power in the Conservative Party: The Hague Effect Politics Review
Vol. 8, No. 3 pp. 28-30
Kelly, R. (2001) Farewell Conference, Hello Forum: The Making of Labour and Tory
Policy The Political Quarterly Vol. 72, No. 3 pp. 329-334
Kelly, R. (2001) Conservatism Under Hague: The Fatal Dilemma Political Quarterly
Vol. 72, No. 2 pp. 197-203
Kelly, R. (2002) The Party Didn’t Work: Conservative Organisation and Electoral
Failure The Political Quarterly Vol. 73, No. 1 pp. 38-43
Kelly, R. (2004) Tough times for the Tories Politics Review Vol. 13, No. 3 pp. 2-5
King, D. S. (1987) The New Right: Politics, Markets and Citizenship London,
Macmillan
Landale, J. (18/7/2001) Clarke’s surge aided by bizarre alliance: Tory leadership
campaign. The Times: page 5
Leach, R. (1996) British Political Ideologies London, Phillip Allan &
Stoughton Lees-Marshment, J. & Quayle, S. (2001) Empowering the Members or Marketing the
Party? The Conservative Reforms of 1998 The Political Quarterly Vol. 72, No. 2 pp.
204-212
Lovenduski, J., Norris, P. & Burness, C. (1994) The Party and Women In. Seldon, A.
& Ball S. (eds) Conservative Century: The Conservative Party Since 1900 Oxford,
Oxford University Press
Ludlam, S. (1996) The Spectre Haunting Conservatism: Europe and Backbench
Rebellion In Ludlam, S. & Smith, M., J. (eds.) Contemporary British Conservatism
London, Macmillan
Ludlam, S. & Smith, M. J. (1996) Introduction In Ludlam, S. & Smith, M., J. (eds.)
Contemporary British Conservatism London, Macmillan
Lynch, P. (1999) The Politics of Nationhood: Sovereignty, Britishness and
Conservative Politics London, Macmillan
Lynch, P. (2003) The Conservatives and Europe In Garnett, M. & Lynch, P. (eds.)
The Conservatives in crisis Manchester, Manchester University Press
Major, J. (1999) John Major: The Autobiography London, Harper Collins
McDowell, R. B. (1959) British Conservatism 1832-1914 London, Faber & Faber
McKenzie, R. (1964) British Political Parties London, Mercury
McLellan, D. (1995) Ideology Buckingham, Open University Press
McSmith A. & Hooley, P. (15/6/1997) Nothing is clear inside Tory hall of mirrors
The Observer: page 22
Norton, P. (1990) ‘The Lady’s Not for Turning’ But What About the Rest? Margaret
Thatcher and the Conservative Party 1979-89 Parliamentary Affairs, Vol. 143, No. 1
pp. 41-58
Norton, P (1993) The Conservative Party from Thatcher to Major In. King, A. (ed.)
Britai at the Polls, 1992 Chatham, Chatham House
Norton, P. (1994) Conservatism In. Foley, M. (ed.) Ideas that shape politics
Manchester, Manchester University Press
Norton, P. (1996a) The Party Leader In. Norton, P. (ed) The Conservative Party
Hemel Hempstead Prentice Hall / Harvester Wheatsheaf
Norton, P. (1996b) The Parliamentary Party and Party Committees In. Seldon, A. &
Ball, S. (eds.) Conservative Century: The Conservative Party since 1900 Oxford,
Oxford University Press Norton, P. (1996c) Factions and Tendencies in the Conservative Party In Margetts, H.
& Smyth, G. (eds.) Turning Japanese? Britain with a Permanent Party of
Government London, Lawrence & Wishart
Norton, P. (1998) The Conservative Party: In Office but not in Power In. King, A.
(ed) New Labour Triumphs: Britain at the Polls Chatham, Chatham House
Nor

Depositing User: Sara Taylor
Date Deposited: 15 May 2008 08:53
Last Modified: 28 Jul 2010 18:23
URI: http://eprints.hud.ac.uk/id/eprint/741

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

Repository Staff Only: item control page

View Item View Item

University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©