Search:
Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

Realist evaluation for practice in Sweden, Finland and Britain

Kazi, Mansoor, Blom, Bjorn, Moren, Stefan, Perdal, Anna-Lena and Rostila, Ilmari (2002) Realist evaluation for practice in Sweden, Finland and Britain. Journal of Social Work Research and Evaluation, 3 (2). pp. 171-186. ISSN 1521-3668

[img] PDF
Restricted to Registered users only

Download (1011kB)

    Abstract

    This article outlines the new, emerging realist paradigm in evaluation research and applies
    it to social work practice in three countries. This paradigm has the potential for a "white
    box" evaluation that not only systematically tracks outcomes but also the mechanisms
    that produce the outcomes, the contexts in which these mechanisms are triggered, and
    the content of the interventions. Human service programs introduce interventions that
    interact with the other causal mechanisms in the contexts of service users to produce
    outcomes. The purpose of realist evaluation is to investigate what works, for whom, and
    in what contexts. Practice examples are provided from Britain, Sweden, and Finland.

    Item Type: Article
    Additional Information: UoA 40 (Social Work and Social Policy and Administration) © 2002 Springer Publishing Company
    Subjects: H Social Sciences > H Social Sciences (General)
    H Social Sciences > HV Social pathology. Social and public welfare
    Schools: School of Human and Health Sciences
    Related URLs:
    References:

    Ahonen, P. (2001). Evaluaatio-oppia edistyville [Evaluation for the advancing learner].
    Hallinnon tutkimus, 20(3), 102-117.
    Anastas, J. W. (1999). Research design for social work and the human services (2nd ed.).
    New York: Columbia University Press.
    Bhaskar, R. (1998). General introduction. In M. Archer, R. Bhaskar, A. Collier, T. Lawson,
    &A. Nome (Eds.), Critical realism: Essential readings (pp. ix-xxiv). London: Routledge.
    Blom, B. (1996). Kurator iprimiirvard. Utviirdering av kuratorsverksamheten vid Skelleftehamns
    vardcentral [Counsellor in primary health care. Evaluation of the counsellor's role at
    Skelleftehamns primary health care unit] (Rapport nr 6). Umea: Umea universitet,
    Institutionen fOr socialt arbete.
    Blom, B. (2001). The personal social services in a Swedish quasi-market context. Policy &
    Politics, 29, 29-42.
    Carlsson, B. (1995). Aft atgiirda eller behandla. En utviirdering av en organisationsforiindring
    inom IFO iNiissjo och dess konsekvenser for klientarbetet [Taking measures or
    to treat. Evaluation of organisational change within the PSS in Nassjo and its consequences
    for the work with clients] (Rapport nr 6). Goteborg: Goteborgs universitet,
    Institutionen fOr socialt arbete.
    Cheetham, J. (1998). The evaluation of social work: Priorities, problems and possibilities. In
    1. Cheetham & M. A. F. Kazi (Eds.), The working of social work. London: Jessica Kingsley.
    Cheetham, J., Fuller, R., Mcivor, G., & Petch, A. (1992). Evaluating social work effectiveness.
    Buckingham, UK: Open University Press.
    Chen, H.-T. (1990). Theory-driven evaluations. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.Danermark, B., Ekstrom, M., & Jakobsen, L. (Eds.). (2002). Explaining society: An introduction
    to critical realism in the social sciences (Bjorn Blom, Trans.). London & New
    York: Routledge. (Original work published 1997)
    Duguid, S., & Pawson, R. (1998). Education, change and transformation: The prison experience.
    Evaluation Review, 22(4),470-495.
    Dufilker, M. (2000). Ostennalmsgatan 54. Utviirdering av ett stOdboende for kvinnor [Ostermalmsgatan
    54. Evaluation of a women's shelter] (Rapport nr 45). Umea, Sweden:
    Umea universitet, Institutionen fOr socialt arbete.
    Dupuy, H. 1. (1984). The Psychological General Well-Being (PGWB) index. In N. Wagner,
    M. E. Mattson, C. F. Furberg, & J. Elinson (Eds.), Assessment of quality of life in clinical
    trials of cardiovascular therapies (pp. 170-183). New York: LeJacq Publishing Inc.
    Ekstrom, M. (1994). Residential relocation, urban renewal and the well-being of elderly
    people. Towards a realist approach. (acta Universitatis Upsaliensis. Comprehensive
    Summaries of Upps ala Dissertations from the Faculty of Social Sciences 42). Uppsala,
    Sweden: Uppsala universitet.
    Fischer, J., & Corcoran, K. (1994). Measures for clinical practice: A source book (Vols. 1
    & 2). New York: The Free Press.
    Forsberg, H. (2000). Lapsen niikokulmaa tavoittamassa. Arviointitutkimus turvakotien
    lapsikeskeisyyttii kehittiiviissii projektissa [Searching the child's perspective. Evaluation
    in a project for developing child-centredness in shelters]. Helsinki: Ensi- ja turvakotien
    Iiiton julkaisu 24.
    Foster, J. L. (1998). Data analysis: Using SPSS for Windows. London: Sage.
    Franke-Wikberg, S., & Lundgren, U. P. (1980). Att utviirdera utbildning [Evaluating education].
    Dell. Stockholm: Wahlstrom & Widstrand.
    Franke- Wikberg, S., & Lundgren, U. P. (1981). Att utviirdera utbildning [Evaluating education].
    Del 2. Stockholm: Wahlstrom & Widstrand.
    Hansson, K., Cederblad, M., & Hook, B. (2000). Funktionell familjeterapi-En behandlingsmetod
    vid ungdomskriminalitet [Functional family therapy. A method for treating
    juvenile delinquents]. Socialvetenskaplig tidskrift, 7, 231-243.
    Hansson, K. (2001). Familjebehandling pa goda grunder: Enforskningsbaserad oversikt
    [Family treatment for good reasons: A research-based overview]. Stockholm: Gothia,
    Centrum fOr utviirdering av socialt arbete (CUS).
    Hedin, U-c., & Mansson, S-A. (1998). Viigen ut! Om kvinnors uppbrott ur prostitutionen
    [The way out! On women's breaking from prostitution]. Stockholm: Carlssons Bokforlag.
    Hedstrom, P., & Swedberg, R. (Eds.). (1998). Social mechanisms. An analytical approach
    to social theory. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
    Holmila, M. (1999). Evaluaatiotutkimuksesta sosiaalitieteissii [Evaluation research in the
    social sciences]. In K. Paakkunainen (Ed.), Arviointitutkimus ja nuoriso. Tulosvastuusta
    dynaamiseen nuorisotoimintaan. Nuorisotutkimusverkosto, Nuorisotutkimusseura,
    julkaisuja 8/1999, 46-60.
    Kaarlejiirvi, J. (2000). Realistinen arviointiteoria koulutuksen arvioinnin teoriakentiissii.
    Viitekehys kuntatason koulutuksen arviointiin [Realistic evaluation theory in the field
    of education evaluation. A framework for municipal level education evaluation]. Hallinnon
    tutkimus, 19(4),368-388.
    Kauppila, T. (2001). Sosiaalityon laadun parantaminen tietotekniikan avulla 1998-2000.
    Loppuraportti [Promoting the quality of social work with the help of information technology
    1998-2000. Final report]. Helsinki: National Research and Development Centre
    for Welfare and Health.
    Kazi, M. A. F. (1998a). Single-case evaluation by social workers. London: Ashgate.Kazi, M. A. F. (1998b). Putting single-case evaluation into practice. In J. Cheetham & M.
    A. F. Kazi (Eds.), The working of social work (pp. 187-199). London: Jessica
    Kingsley.
    Kazi, M. A. F. (1998c). Scientific realist evaluation of social work practice. Paper presented
    at the European Evaluation Society's Conference, International Conference on
    Evaluation, Rome, Italy.
    Kazi, M. A. F. (1999). Paradigmatic influences in practice research: A critical assessment.
    In M. Potocky-Tripodi & T. Tripodi (Eds.), New directions for social work practice
    research. Washington, DC: NASW Press.
    Kazi, M. A. F. (2000a). Contemporary perspectives in the evaluation of practice. British
    Journal of Social Work, 30, 755-768.
    Kazi, M. A. F. (2000b). Evaluation of social work practice in England. Journal of Social
    Work Research And Evaluation, i(2), 101-109.
    Kazi, M. A. F., Smith, M., & Clarke, B. (2002, January). Single-subject and realist evaluation
    of a group work program with young offenders. Paper presented at Society For
    Social Work & Research 6th Annual Conference, San Diego, CA.
    Kuosmanen, J. (2001). Finnkampen: En studie av finska miins liv och sociala karriiirer i
    Sverige [The Finn battle: A study of Finish men's lives and social careers in Sweden]
    (Rapport nr 2). Goteborg: Goteborgs universitet, Institutionen fOr socialt arbete.
    Lawson, T. (1998). Economic science without experimentation/abstraction. In M. Archer,
    R. Bhaskar, A. Collier, T. Lawson, & A. Norrie (Eds.), Critical realism: Essential
    readings (pp. 144-185). London: Routledge.
    Lindqvist, T. (1996). Miten tukea ihmisten selviytymistii? Sosiaalityko-kurssien evaluaatiotutkimus.
    [How to support the coping of the unemployed? Evaluation of rehabilitative
    educational courses]. Helsinki: Helsingin kaupungin sosiaalivirasto D: 1/1996.
    Lindberg, O. (1998). Emotioner, sociala band och ritualer: En kvalitativ analys av narkotikakarriiirer
    [Emotions, social bonds and rituals: A qualitative analysis of drug careers]
    (Rapport nr 2). Goteborg: Goteborgs universitet, Institutionen fOr socialt arbete.
    Lohiniemi, S., Mustalahti, K., Collin, P., Vuolteenaho, N., Rostila, I., & Mm, M. (in press).
    Quality of life in Finnish coeliac disease patients-A nationwide cross-sectional survey.
    Tampere, Finland: University of Tampere.
    Mantysaari, M. (1991). Sosiaalibyrokratia asiakkaiden valvojana [Social bureaucracy in
    controlling clients]. Sosiaalipoliittisen yhdistyksen tutkimuksia 51. Tampere: Vastapaino.
    Mantysaari, M. (1999). Toimeentulotuki tyollistajana. Lahden tyOllisUimispalveluprojektin
    arviointia [Employment through income support. Evaluating a special service for
    unemployed in Lahti]. Helsinki: Sosiaali-ja terveysalan tutkimus- ja kehittamiskeskus.
    FinSoc. Sosiaalihuollon menetelmien arviointiprojekti, tyopapereita 3.
    Macdonald, G., Sheldon, B., & Gillespie, J. (1992). Contemporary studies of the effectiveness
    of social work. British Journal of Social Work, 22,615-643.
    Markstrom, U. (1998). Pro-eller jiikt. En utviirdering av Niitkrajt, ett arbetsrehabiliteringsprojekt
    for funktionshindrande [Project or rush. Evaluation of Natkraft, a work rehabilitation
    project for disabled] (Skrift nr 3). Umea: Utvecklings- och faltforskningsenheten
    (UFFE) vid Umea socialtjanst.
    Moren, S. (1992). Foriindringens gestalt. Om villkorenfor miinskligt bistand [The gestalt
    of change. On the conditions for human assistance]. Stockholm: Publica.
    Moren, S. (1994a). Social work is beautiful. On the characteristics of social work. Scandinavian
    Journal of Social Welfare, 3, 158-166.
    Moren, S. (1994b). Social work organizations from within. international Social Work, 37,
    277-293.Moren, S. (1996). Att utvardera socialt arbete [Evaluating social work practice]. Stockholm:
    Publica.
    Moren, S., & Blom, B. (2000a). The research profile: Interventions and results in social
    work practice-A first analysis. Paper presented at the Researchers' seminar: Does
    Social Welfare Pay, at the School of Social Work, Stockholm University, Sweden.
    Moren, S., & Blom, B. (2000b). Interventions and results in social work practice-A research
    profile. Paper presented at the International conference: Evaluation for practice, at the
    University of Huddersfield, England.
    Nygren, L., & Soydan, H. (1997). Social work research and its dependence on practice.
    Scandinavian Journal of Social Welfare, 6,217-224.
    Parton, N., & O'Byrne (2000). Constructive social work: Towards a new practice. London:
    Macmillan.
    Pawson, R., &Tilley, N. (1997a). An introduction to scientific realist evaluation. In Chelimsky,
    E., & Shadish, W. R. (Eds.). Evaluation for the 21st Century: A resource book (pp.
    405-418). Thousand Oaks: Sage.
    Pawson, R., & Tilley, N. (1997b). Realistic evaluation. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
    Perdal, A. L. (2000). Documentation of interventions as a tool in social work: A model for
    self-evaluation and in-organisation supervision. Paper presented at the International
    conference: Evaluation for practice, at the University of Huddersfield, England.
    Reid, W. 1. (1994). The empirical practice movement. Social Service Review, 68, 165-184.
    Rostila, I. (2000). Realistinen arviointitutkimus ja onnistumisen pakot [Realist evaluation
    and the pressures to succeed]. In R. Laitinen (Ed.), Arvioinnin arkeaja peruskysymyksiii
    (pp. 69-99). Helsinki: Sosiaali-ja terveysturvan Keskusliitto.
    Rostila, I. (2001). Sosiaalisen kuntoutuksen mekanismit. Monet-projektin realistinen arviointi.
    [Mechanisms of social rehabilitation. Realist evaluation of the Monet project]. Helsinki:
    National Research and Development Centre for Welfare and Health.
    Rostila, I., & Kazi, M. A. F. (2001). Realistinen arviointitutkimus toimintamallin kehittarnisen
    valineena. [Realist evaluation as a means of developing models of practice]. In P.Vartiainen
    (Ed.), Niikokulmia projektiarviointiin. Tasapainottelua taloudellisessa, hallinnollisessa
    ja sosiaalisessa kontekstissa [Perpectives for evaluating projects. Balancing in economical,
    admistrative and social context] (pp. 69-99). Tampere: Finnpublishers.
    Rostila, I., & Torniainen, K (1999). Mikii toimii? Monet-projektin toiminnan viiliarviointi
    1999. [What works? The interim evaluation of the Monet project]. Helsinki: National
    Research and Development Centre for Welfare and Health.
    Saarnio, P., Tolonen, M., Heikkila, K, Kangassalo, S., Makelliinen, M-L., Niitty-Uotila, P.,
    Vilenius, L., & Virtanen, K (1998). Pliihdeongelmaisten selviytyminen hoidon jalkeen.
    [The coping of alcoholics after care]. Sosiaaliliiiiketieteellinen aikakauslehti, 35, 207-219.
    Scriven, M. (1994). The fine line between evaluation and explanation. Evaluation Practice,
    15(1),75-77.
    Suikkanen, A. (2001). Kuntoutuksen arviointi-Realistinen nak6kulma [Evaluating rehabilitation-
    A realist perspective]. Fysioterapia, 48( 1), 4-8.
    Sundman, P. (1993). Avioliitto-ja perheneuvonnan vaikuttavuus [The effectiveness of family
    counselling]. Helsinki: Helsingin kaupunki, Sosiaaliviraston julkaisusarja A7.
    Taylor, c., & White, S. (2000). Practising reflexivity in health and welfare. Buckingham,
    UK: Open University Press.
    Tengvald, K (1995). Behov av resultatorienterad kunskapsutveckling i socialt arbete [The
    need for result oriented development of knowledge in social work]. In SOU 1995:58
    Kompetens och kunskapsutveckling. Stockholm: The Ministry of Health and Social
    Affairs.Thyer, B. A. (1993). Social work theory and practice research: The approach oflogical positivism.
    Social Work and Social Sciences Review, 4, 5-26.
    Thyer, B. A. (1998). Promoting evaluation research on social work practice. In J. Cheetham
    & M. A. F. Kazi, (Eds.), The working of social work. London: Jessica Kingsley.
    Toivonen, T. (1998). Empiirinen sosiaalitutkimus. Filosofiaja metodologia [Empirical social
    research. Philosophy and methodology]. Porvoo: WSOY.

    Depositing User: Sara Taylor
    Date Deposited: 02 Nov 2007
    Last Modified: 28 Jul 2010 19:21
    URI: http://eprints.hud.ac.uk/id/eprint/466

    Document Downloads

    Downloader Countries

    More statistics for this item...

    Item control for Repository Staff only:

    View Item

    University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©