Search:
Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

Abortion in post-Communist Germany: the end of muttipolitik and a still birth for feminism

Fisher, Pamela (2005) Abortion in post-Communist Germany: the end of muttipolitik and a still birth for feminism. Women's Studies International Forum, 28 (1). pp. 21-36. ISSN 0277-5395

[img] PDF
Restricted to Registered users only

Download (190kB)

    Abstract

    Abortion proved to be the most emotive issue in the process of unifying Germany post-1989. Attempts to create uniform abortion legislation applicable throughout Germany revealed an ideological chasm that separated the conservative discourse of the west from those on the Left, in particular in eastern Germany. The narratives of former women supporters of the ruling communist regime in East Germany are considered. These women regarded the imposition of more restrictive reproductive laws on eastern Germany in terms of an assault against the moral status of the German Democratic Republic (GDR) and, in some cases, as instrumental in quelling an unanticipated upsurge of feminist consciousness that occurred in eastern Germany in 1989 and 1990. The role of the women's experience of East German social policy, in particular Muttipolitik, which emphasised women's dual roles as workers and mothers, is considered in relation to its impact on the interviewees' responses to the abortion debate. It is suggested that the brief burgeoning of feminist consciousness in 1989/1990 was, in part, instigated but also quashed by the dominance of western discourse that required a total rejection of the GDR legacy, including liberal abortion laws

    Item Type: Article
    Additional Information: UoA 41 (Sociology) © 2005 Elsevier Ltd.
    Subjects: H Social Sciences > H Social Sciences (General)
    H Social Sciences > HM Sociology
    Schools: School of Human and Health Sciences
    Related URLs:
    References:

    Alsop, Rachel, & Hockey, Jenny (2001). Women’s reproductive
    rights as a symbolic resource in central and Eastern Europe. The
    European Journal of Women’s Studies, 8(4), 457–471.
    Banaszak, Lee Ann (1998). East–West differences in German
    abortion opinion. Public Opinion Quarterly, 62(4), 545– 582.
    Behrend, Hanna (Ed.) (1995a). German unification. The destruction
    of an economy. East Haven, CT7 Pluto Press.
    Behrend, Hanna (1995b). East German women and the Wende.
    European Journal of Women’s Studies, 2(2), 237–256.
    Berghahn, Sabine (1995). Gender in the legal discourse in postunification
    Germany: Old and new lines of conflict. Social
    Politics Spring, 37–50.
    Biester, Elke, Holland-Cunz, Barbara, Maleck-Lewy Eva, Ruf Anja,
    & Sauer, Birgit (Eds.) (1994). Gleichstellungspolitik—Totem
    und Tabus. Eine feministische Revision (pp. 38– 52). Frankfurt7
    Campus.
    Blay, Sam, & Piotrowicz, Ryszard (1993). The advance of German
    unification and the abortion debate. Statute Law Review, 14(3),
    171–185.
    Bfhm, Tatiana (1992). The abortion question: A new solution in
    unified Germany? German Politics and Society, 24 and 25,
    135–141.
    Bundeszentrale fqr politische Bildung (1991). Vertra¨ge zur deutschen
    Einheit. Bonn7 Clausen and Bosse, Leck.
    Carlin, Wendy (1999). The new east German economy: Problems of
    transition, unification and institutional mismatch. In Chris
    Flockton, & Eva Kolinsky (Eds.), Recasting East Germany.
    Social transformation after the GDR. London7 Frank Cass.
    Clements, Elizabeth (1994). The abortion debate in unified Germany.
    In Elizabeth Boa, & Janet Wharton (Eds.), German monitor.
    Women and the Wende: Social effects and cultural reflections of
    the German unification process, vol. 31 (pp. 38– 52).
    Deneke, Marlies (1990). Ein neuer Anspruch von Frauen. Denkans7tze
    fqr eine Frauenpolitik. In Gregor Gysi (Ed.), Wir
    brauchen einen dritten Weg. Selbstverst7ndnis und Programm
    der PDS. Hamburg7 Konkret Literatur Verlag.
    Dflling, Irene (1991). Between hope and helplessness: Women in
    the GDR after the dturning pointT. Feminist Review, 39, 3– 15.
    Einhorn, Barbara (1993). Cinderella goes to market. London7
    Verso.
    Einhorn, Barbara (1995). Feminism in crisis: The east German
    women’s movement in the bNew EuropeQ. Australian Journal of
    Politics and History, 41(1), 14– 28.
    Ferree, Myra Marx (1992). Institutionalizing gender equality:
    Feminist politics and equality offices. German Politics and
    Society, 24 and 25, 53–66.
    Finzel, Eva (2003). dEqualityT for women, child rearing, and the
    state in the former German democratic republic. Women’s
    Studies International Forum, 26(1), 37–56.
    Fisher, Pamela (2002a). Post-communist feminism in Germany:
    Equality and difference in the party of democratic socialism.
    German Politics and Society, 20(1), 68– 91.
    Fisher, Pamela (2002b). Creating a Marxist–Leninist cultural
    identity: Women’s memories of the German democratic republic’s.
    Friedensfahrt. Culture, Sport, Society, 5(1), 39– 52.
    Fulbrook, Mary (1997). Reckoning with the Past: Heroes, victims
    and villains in the history of the German democratic republic. In
    Reinhard Alter, & Peter Monteath (Eds.), Rewriting the German
    past. New Jersey7 Humanities Press.
    Gal, Susan, & Kligman, Gail (2000a). The politics of gender after
    socialism. Princeton7 Princeton University Press.
    Gal, Susan, & Kligman, Gail (2000b). Reproducing gender. Politics,
    publics and everyday life after socialism. Princeton7 Princeton
    University Press.
    Hampele Ulrich, Anne (1993). The organised women’s movement
    in the collapse of the GDR: The independent women’s
    association (UFV). In Nanette Funk, & Magda Mueller (Eds.),
    Gender politics and post-communism. Reflections from eastern
    Europe and the former Soviet Union. London7 Routledge.
    Hampele Ulrich, Anne (2000). Der Unabha¨ngige Frauenverband.
    Ein frauenpolitisches Experiment im deutschen Vereinigungsprozeg.
    Berlin7 Berliner Debatte Wissenschaftsverlag.
    Harsch, Donna (1997). Society, the state, and abortion in East
    Germany, 1950–1972. American Historical Review, 2, 53– 84.
    Haug, Frigga (1991). Socialist feminism. Feminist Review, 39,
    37– 57.
    Hornbogen, Lothar, Nakath, Detlef, & Stephan, Gerd-Rqdiger
    (Eds.) (1999). Augerordentlicher Parteitag der SED/PDS.
    Protokoll der Beratungen am 8./9. Und 16./17. Dezember
    1989 in Berlin. Berlin7 Dietz Verlag.
    Jarausch, Konrad (1994). The rush to German unity. Oxford7
    Oxford University Press.
    Jesse, Echhard (Ed.) (2000). Eine Revolution und ihre Folgen.
    Berlin7 Ch. Links Verlag.
    Kenawi, Samirah (1995). bAufstieg einer ProblemgruppeQ. Themen
    und Taktikwechsel der ostdeutschen Frauenbewegung. In ZIF
    (Ed.), Unter Hammer und Zirkel. Frauenbiographien vor dem
    Hintergrund ostdeutscher Sozialisierungserfahrungen. Berlin7
    Humboldt University.Kolinsky, Eva (1995). Women in 20th century Germany. Manchester7
    Manchester University Press.
    Kontos, Silva (1979). Die Partei ka¨mpft wie ein Mann: Frauenpolitik
    der KPD in der Weimarer Republik. Frankfurt am Main7
    Roter Stern.
    Kuhrig, Herta (1990). Gleichstellung—Schein und Wirklichkeit.
    Zur kritischen Bilanz 40j7hriger DDR-Entwicklung unter dem
    Blickwinkel der Geschlechterproblematik. In Lisa (Ed.) (1992),
    Controvers. Von einer m7nnlichen zu einer menschlichen Welt.
    Berlin: PDS-Literaturvertrieb Kleine Alexanderstrage.
    Lieser-Triebnigg, Erika (1995). Neuregelung des Abtreibungsrechts.
    Deutschland Archiv, 28(8), 785– 786.
    Maleck-Lewy, Eva (1995). Between self-determination and state
    supervision: Women and the abortion law in postunification
    Germany. Social Politics, 2(1), 62– 75.
    Maleck-Lewy, Eva (1998). Kein Ende in Sicht: Die Auseinandersetzung
    um den Paragraphen 218. Feminia politica: Zeitschrift
    fu¨r feministische Politik-Wissenschaft, 1, 88– 93.
    Maleck-Lewy, Eva, & Ferree, Myra Marx (2000). Abortion,
    reproductive rights in the GDR. In Susan Gail, & Gail
    Kligman (Eds.), Reproducing gender. Politics, publics and
    everyday life after socialism. New Jersey7 Princeton University
    Press.
    Mocker, Elke, & Sauer, Birgit (1991). Politische Kultur und
    Geschlechterverh7ltnis in den neuen Bundesl7ndern. Zur politischen
    Partizipation von Frauen seit der Wende. Deutschland
    Archiv, 24(12), 1313–1323.
    Mushaben, Joyce Marie (1997). Concession or compromise? The
    politics of abortion in United Germany. German Politics, 6(3),
    70– 88.
    Neuke, Elke (1994). Weibliche Wertvorstellungen—zwischen
    Schein und Sein. In Birgit, & Heidi Stecker (Eds.), Eigenartige
    Ostfrauen. Frauenemanzipation in der DDR und in den neuen
    Bundesla¨ndern. Bielefeld7 Kleine Verlag.
    Nickel, Hildegard Maria (1993). Geschlechterverh7ltnisse in der
    Wende. Individualisierung versus Solidarisierung? Deutschland
    Archiv, 26, 1127– 1137.
    Nimsch, Margarethe (1992). Abortion as politics. German Politics
    and Society, 24 and 25, 128– 134.
    Oakley, Ann (1981). Interviewing women: A contradiction in terms.
    In Helen Roberts (Ed.), Doing feminist research. London7
    Routledge and Kegan Paul.
    Ostner, Ilona (1998). Gender, family and the welfare state—
    Germany before and after unification. In Eva Kolinksy (Ed.),
    Social transformation and the family in post-communist
    Germany. UK7 Macmillan Press.
    Prqtzel-Thomas, Monika (1993). The abortion issue and the Federal
    Constitutional Court. German Politics, 2(3), 467–484.
    Prqtzel-Thomas, Monika (1995). The abortion issue since unification.
    Are women the losers? Debatte, 3(2), 105–120.
    Rattinger, Hans (1994). Attitudes towards the Abortion Law in
    Germany, 1990–1992: Determinants and political implications.
    German Politics, 3(2), 249– 264.
    Roensch, Hannelore (1992). Der bessere Schutz ungeborener
    Kinder im Vereinten Deutschland—Chance und Verantwortung
    der CDU. In Andrea Hauner, & Elke Reichart (Eds.), § 218: Zur
    aktuellen Diskussion. Munich7 Kanaur.
    Rosenberg, Dorothy (1992). Women’s issues, women’s politics, and
    women’s studies in the Former German Democratic Republic.
    Radical History Review, 54, 110– 126.
    Sch7fer, Eva (1990). bWer sich nicht wehrt, kommt an den Herd!Q
    Zur feministischen Erneuerung in der DDR. Das Argument, 180,
    273– 280.
    Schmidt, G. (1995). Zwei rivalisierende Demokratie-Modelle: Ein
    Beitrag zum Verst7ndnis der PDS. Deutschland Archiv, 28(8),
    835– 841.
    Sharp, Ingrid (1994). Male privilege and female virtue: Gendered
    representations of the two Germanies. New German Studies,
    18(1/2), 87–106.
    Smyth, Lisa (2002). Feminism and abortion politics: Choice, rights,
    and reproductive freedom. Women’s Studies International
    Forum, 25(3), 335– 345.
    Smyth, Lisa (2002). Feminism and abortion politics: Choice, rights,
    and reproductive freedom. Women’s Studies International
    Forum, 25, 335–345.
    Sbrensen, Annemette, & Trappe, Heike (1995). The persistence of
    gender equality in earnings in the German democratic republic.
    American Sociological Review, 60(3), 398– 406.
    Streit, Petra (1992). Raising consciousness. German Politics and
    Society, 24 and 25, 10– 15.
    Sumner, L. Wayne (1981). Abortion and moral theory. New Jersey7
    Princeton University Press.
    Thietz, Kirsten (Ed.) (1992). Ende der Selbstversta¨ndlichkeit? Die
    Abschaffung des §218 in der DDR. Dokumente. Berlin7 Dietz
    Verlag.
    Weitz, Eric (1997). Creating German communism, 1890–1990.
    Princeton7 Princeton University Press.
    Wuerth, Andrea (1999). Abortion rights activism in post wall
    Berlin. Feminist Studies, 25(3), 601–631.
    Young, Brigitte (1996). The German state and feminist politics:
    A double gender marginalization. Social Politics, 3(2–3),
    150– 184.
    Young, Brigitte (1999). Triumph of the fatherland. German
    unification and the marginalisation of women. Michigan7
    University of Michigan Press.

    Depositing User: Sara Taylor
    Date Deposited: 12 Oct 2007
    Last Modified: 28 Jul 2010 19:21
    URI: http://eprints.hud.ac.uk/id/eprint/438

    Document Downloads

    Downloader Countries

    More statistics for this item...

    Item control for Repository Staff only:

    View Item

    University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©