Search:
Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

Quantitative characterisation of surface finishes on stainless steel sheet using 3D surface topography analysis

Waterworth, Adelle (2006) Quantitative characterisation of surface finishes on stainless steel sheet using 3D surface topography analysis. Doctoral thesis, University of Huddersfield.

[img]
Preview
PDF
Adelle_Waterworth_Thesis.pdf

Download (9MB) | Preview

Abstract

The main aim of this project was to quantitatively characterise the developed surface
topography of finishes on stainless steel sheet using three-dimensional surface analysis
techniques.
At present surface topography is measured using (mainly) stylus profilometry and analysed with
2D parameters, such as Ra, Rq and Rz. These 2D measurements are not only unreliable due to
a lack of standardised measurement methodology, but are also difficult to relate directly to the
actual shape of the topography in 3 dimensions. They bear little direct relation to the functional
properties of the surface of stainless steel, making them less useful than their 3D counterparts.
Initially it is crucial to ensure that the surface topography data collected is correct, accurate and
relevant, by defining a measurement strategy. Models of the surface topography are developed
encompassing the usual features of the topography and variations in the topography caused by
production or 'defects'. The functional features are discussed and predicted relevant parameters
are presented.
The protocol covers the selection of the correct measuring instrument based on the surface
model and the size of the relevant functional features so that the desired lateral and vertical
resolution and range is achievable. Measurement data is then analysed using Fast Fourier
Transforms (FFTs) to separate the different frequencies within the spatial frequencies detected
on the surface. The frequency of the important features shows up dominantly on a Power
Spectral Density (PSD) plot and this is used to find the correct sampling interval to accurately
reconstruct the 3D surface data. The correct instrument for further measurements is then
selected using a Steadman diagram. Operational details of the measuring instruments available
for this project are given and variables for these instruments are discussed. Finally,
measurement method recommendations are made for each of the four finishes modelled.
Based on this surface characterisation an attempt is made to identify the 3D parameters that
give a quantitative description of common stainless steel sheet finishes with respect to some
aspects of their production and functional performance.
An investigation of the differences in manufacturing processes, gauge and grade of material is
presented, providing an insight into the effect on topography of such divergences. The
standardised 3D parameter set is examined to determine its sensitivity to common variations in
the topography of the 2B finish and therefore their potential relevance.
A new data separation technique of the material probability curve for use on the 3D datasets
establishes a cut-off (transition point) between the two main functionally relevant features of the
2B surface (plateaus and valleys) by finding the intersection of the asymptotes of a fitted conic
section, giving a non subjective methodology to establish the section height. The standardised
3D parameters are then used on the separated data, with the aim of being more functionally
relevant to the main surface studied.
Functional tests to rate capability of these parameters in the areas of optical appearance,
lubricant retention and corrosion are carried out and the appropriate topography parameters are
related to their performance.

▼ Jump to Download Statistics
Item Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Additional Information: © The Author 2006
Uncontrolled Keywords: Three dimensional measurement, surface characterisation, stainless steel sheet
Subjects: Q Science > Q Science (General)
Q Science > QC Physics
Q Science > QA Mathematics > QA76 Computer software
Schools: School of Computing and Engineering
References:

[1] Whitehouse D.J., Bowen D.K., Venkatesh V.C., Leonardo P., & Brown C.A., ‘Gloss and
Surface Topography’, Annals of the CIRP, vol. 2, 1-9, 1994
[2] Duieu D., Private Communication, 2003
[3] BSEN 10088-2:1995, ‘Technical delivery conditions for sheet/plate and strip for general
purposes’, 1995
[4] Freeman P. F., Hargate N., Barrett R. L., ‘Finger Print Resistant Stainless Steel’, 4th
European Stainless Steel Science and Market Congress, Paris, 2002
[5] Crookes R., ‘Materials and Applications Series, Volume 4 - Pickling and Passivating
Stainless Steel’, Published online at http://www.worldstainless.org/articles/ss_passivate.pdf,
2004
[6] Stout K.J. & Davis E.J., ‘Surface topography of cylinder bores – the relationship between
manufacture, characterisation and function’, Wear, 95, pp. 111-125, 1984
[7] Pawlus P. and Chetwynd D.G., ‘Efficient Characterisation of Surface Topography in Cylinder
Bores‘, Precision Engineering, Vol. 19, pp. 164-174, 1996
[8] Whitehouse D.J., ‘Handbook of Surface Metrology’, Institute of Physics Publishing, 1994
[9] Sullivan P.J., Poroshin V. & Hooke C.J., ‘An Application of a Three Dimensional Surface
Analysis System to the Prediction of Asperity Interaction in Metallic Contacts’, 5th International
Conference on the Metrology and Properties of Engineering Surfaces, 1991
[10] Vermeulen M., De Boeck A., Claessens S., Antonissen J., Scheers J., ‘Sheet Metal
Processing, Texturing and Coating Methods in view of Application Manufacturing Steps’,
Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Sheet Metal, Belgium, pp 3-26, 2001.
[11] Faraq M.M., ‘Materials Selection for Engineering’, Prentice Hall. 1997
[12] Smith K.B., ‘A Sharper Look at Gloss’, Surface Coatings International, Journal of the Oil
and Colour Chemits’ Association, Vol. 80, pp. 573-576, December 1997
[13] Adelson E. H., ‘Lightness perception and lightness illusions’, The Cognitive Neurosciences,
pages 339–351, 1999
[14] Hunter R.S. & Harold R.W., ‘The measurement of appearance’, 2nd edition, John Wiley &
Sons, 1987
[15] Ingersoll L.R., ‘A means to measure the glare of paper’, Electronics World, Vol. 60, pp. 645-
647, 1914
[16] Thomas T.R.,‘Rough Surfaces‘, Longman Press, London, 1982 [17] F Sacerdotti, B J Griffiths, C Butler, F Benati, ‘Surface topography in autobody
manufacture—the state of the art’, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part
B: Journal of Engineering Manufacture, Vol. 214, No. 9, pp. 811 – 820, 2000
[18] Steinhoff K., Rasp W., Pawelski O., ‘Development of deterministic–stochastic surface
structures to improve the tribological conditions of sheet forming processes’, Journal of Material
Process Technology, Vol. 60, No. 1-4, pp 355–61, 1996
[19] Jonasson M., Wihlborg A., Gunnarsson L., ‘Analysis of surface topography changes in steel
sheet strips during bending under tension friction test’, Int. J. Mach. tools Manufact., Vol. 38, No.
5-6, pp. 459-467, 1998
[20] Wihlborg A., Crafoord R., ‘Frictional study of uncoated steel sheets’, Proceedings of
International Conference on Technology of Plasticity, 1999
[21] Meiler M., Pfestorf M., Geiger M., Merklein M., ‘The use of dry film lubricants in aluminum
sheet metal forming’, Wear, Vol. 255, pp. 1455–1462, 2003
[22] Blunt L., ‘The Development of a Basis for 3D Surface Roughness Standards – Surfstand
Final Report’, not published, Commission of the European Communities Project Number
3374/1/0/170/90/2, 2001
[23] Vermeulen M., De Boeck A., Claessens S., Antonissen J., Scheers J., ‘Sheet Metal
Processing, Texturing and Coating Methods in view of Application Manufacturing Steps’,
Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Sheet Metal, Belgium, pp 3-26, 2001
[24] Jonasson M., Wihlborg A., Gunnarsson L., ‘Analysis of surface topography changes in steel
sheet strips during bending under tension friction test’, Int. J. Mach. tools Manufact., Vol. 38, No.
5-6, pp. 459-467, 1998
[25] Leslie W.C., ‘The physical metallurgy of steels’, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, 1981
[26] Trethewey K.R. & Chamberlain J., ‘Corrosion for science and engineering’, 2nd edition,
Longman Scientific and Technical, 1995.
[27] Freeman P., Private communication, 2002
[28] Moayed M.H., Laycock N.J., Newman R.C., ‘Dependence of the Critical Pitting
Temperature on surface roughness’, Corrosion Science, Vol. 45 , pp. 1203–1216, 2003
[29] Schmaltz G., ‘Technische Oberflächenkunde’, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1936
[30] Abbott E., Bousky S. and Williamson D.E., ‘The Profilometer’, Mechanical Engineering,
Vol.60, pp. 205-216, 1938
[31] Reason R.E., Hopkins M.R. and Garrod R.I., ‘Report on the Measurement of Surface Finish
by Stylus Methods‘, Taylor-Hobson, Leicester, 1944
[32] Williamson J.B.P., ‘Microtopography of Surfaces‘, Proceedings of the Institution of
Mechanical Engineers, Vol. 182, Part 3K, pp. 21-30, 1967-8 [33] Peklenik J. and Kubo M.,‘A Basic Study of a Three Dimensional Assessment of the Surface
Generated in a Manufacturing Process‘, Annals of the CIRP, Vol. 16, pp. 257-265, 1967-8
[34] Sayles R.S. and Thomas T.R.,‘Mapping a Small Area of a Surface‘, Journal of Physics E:
Scientific Instruments, Vol. 9, pp. 855-861, 1976
[35] Stout K.J., ‘Three Dimensional Surface Topography; Measurement, Interpretation and
Applications’, Penton Press, 1994, ISBN 1-85718-004-6
[36] Mummery L., ‘Surface Texture Analysis – The Handbook‘, Hommelwerke GmbH, 1992
[37] Peklenik J. and Kubo M.,‘A Basic Study of a Three Dimensional Assessment of the Surface
Generated in a Manufacturing Process‘, Annals of the CIRP, Vol. 16, pp. 257-265, 1967-8
[38] Dagnall H., ‘Exploring surface texture (2nd edition)‘, Rank Taylor Hobson Limited, 1986
[39] Thomas, T.R., Rough Surfaces, 2nd ed., Imperial College Press, London (1999).
[40] Lippold S. and Podlesny J., ‘WYKO Surface Profilers - Technical Reference Manual‘, ©
Wyko Corporation, May 1996
[41] Stout K.J., Sullivan P.J., Dong W.P., Mainsah E., Luo N., Mathia T., Zahouani H., ‘The
Development of Methods for the Characterisation of Roughness in Three Dimensions’,
published on behalf of the Commission of the European Communities, Number
3374/1/0/170/90/2, ISBN 0 7044 1313 2, 1993.
[42] Baselt D., ‘The Tip-Sample Interaction in Atomic Force Microscopy and its Implications for
Biological Applications‘, Ph.D. thesis for California Institute of Technology, published on
http://stm2.nrl.navy.mil/how-afm/how-afm.html, Copyright © David Baselt, 1993
[43] ThermoMicroscopes, ‘A Practical Guide to Scanning Probe Microscopy ‘, for Park Scientific
Instruments and TopoMetrix (Thermo Electron), published on http://www.thermomicro.com/,
1997
[44] DME, ‘DME-DualScope / RasterScope 5000 General Installation Manual‘, Version 1.1 ©
DME (Danish Micro Engineering), 1998
[45] Binnig G., Quate C.F. and Gerber C., ‘Atomic Force Microscope‘, Physical review letters,
Vol. 56, No. 9, pp. 930-933, 1986
[46] Iowa State University Materials Science and Engineering Department, SEM images
published on http://mse.iastate.edu/microscopy/path.html, accessed 2004
[47] Goldstein J.I., ‘Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-ray Microanalysis’, 3rd edition,
Kluewer Press, 2003
[48] Steadman M., ‘Basis for Comparing the Performance of Surface-Measuring Instruments’,
Precision Engineering, Vol. 9 (3), pp.149-152, 1987
[49] Thomas T.R., Private communication, 1999 [50] Bendat J.S. and Piersol A.G., ‘Random Data: Analysis and Measurment Procedures‘,
Wiley-Interscience, 1971, ISBN 0-471-06470-X
[51] Kubo M. and Peklenik J., ‘An Analysis of Micro-geometrical Isotropy for Random Surface
Structures‘, Annals of the CIRP, Vol. 16, pp. 235-242, 1968
[52] Lin T.Y., Blunt L. and Stout K.J., ‘Determination of Proper Frequency Banwidth for 3D
Topography Measurement using Spectral Analysis. Part 1: Isotropic Surfaces‘, Wear, Vol. 166,
pp. 221-232, 1993
[53] Tsukada T. and Sasajima K., ‘An Optimum Sampling Interval for Digitising Surface Asperity
Profiles‘, 2nd International Conference on the Metrology and Properties of Engineering
Surfaces, 1982
[54] Tsukada T. and Kanada T., ‘Evaluation of Two and Three Dimensional Surface Roughness
Profile and their Confidence‘, Wear, Vol. 109 (1-4), pp. 69-78, 1986
[55] Pawlus P. and Chetwynd D.G., ‘Efficient Characterisation of Surface Topography in
Cylinder Bores‘, Precision Engineering, Vol. 19, pp. 164-174, 1996
[56] Pfestorf M., Engel U., Geiger M., ‘3D-Surface parameters and their application on
deterministic textured metal sheets’, Proc. 7th Int. Conf. on Metrology and Properties of
Engineering Surfaces, 1997
[57] Anamalay R.V., Kirk T.B., Panzera D., ‚Numerical descriptors for the analysis of wear
surfaces using scanning confocal microscopy’, Wear, Vol. 181-183, pp.771-776, 1995
[58] Sullivan P., Poroshin V., Hooke C., ‘Application of a three-dimensional surface analysis
system to the prediction of asperity interaction in metallic contacts’, International Journal of
Machne Tools and Manufacture, Vol. 32, No. ½, pp. 157-169, 1992
[59] Dobbin E., ‘Quantitative Characterisation of 2B Surface Finishes on Stainless Steels using
3D Surface Topography Analysis’, not published, 1998.
[60] Whitehouse D.J., ‘Parameter Rash – Is there a Cure?’, Wear 83 (pp. 75-78), 1982.
[61] Brooker K., ‘Manual of British Standards in Engineering Metrology‘, British Standards
Institution, London, 1984
[62] Blunt L. A., Jiang X., ‘Advanced techniques for assessment surface topography:
development of a basis for 3D surface texture standards "surfstand"’, Kogan Page Science,
2003
[63] Von Weingraber H., ‘Suitability of the Envelope Line as a Reference Standard for
Measuring Roughness‘, Microtecnic, Vol. 11, pp.6-17, 1957
[64] DIN 4776, ‘Measurement of Surface Roughness; Parameters Rk, Rpk, Rvk, Mr1, Mr2 for
the Description of the Material Portion in the Roughness‘, German Standard Din 4776, 1990 [65] Blunt L., ‘The Development of a Basis for 3D Surface Roughness Standards – Surfstand
2nd Year Progress Report’, not published, Commission of the European Communities Project
Number 3374/1/0/170/90/2, 2000
[66] Blunt L., Jiang X. and Stout K.J.,‘Developments in 3D Surface Metrology‘, Proc. Int. Conf.
Lambdamap, Southampton, July 1999
[67] Lin T.Y., Blunt L. and Stout K.J., ‘Determination of Proper Frequency Banwidth for 3D
Topography Measurement using Spectral Analysis. Part 1: Isotropic Surfaces‘, Wear, Vol. 166,
pp. 221-232, 1993
[68] Lin T.Y., ‘Characterisation, Sampling and Measurement Variation of Surface Topography: A
Viewpoint from Standardisation‘, Ph.D. thesis for School of Manufacturing and Mechanical
Engineering, University of Birmingham, U.K., not published, 1993
[69] Wihlborg A.H., ‘The Influence of Steel Sheet Surface Topography on Friction in Stamping‘,
Ph.D. thesis for Department of Production Engineering, Chalmers University, Sweden,
published © Anders H. Wihlborg, 2000, ISBN 91-7197-885-2
[70] DIN, ‘Measurement of Surface Roughness; Parameters Rk, Rpk, Rvk, Mr1, Mr2 for the
Description of the Material Portion in the Roughness‘, German Standard Din 4776, 1990
[71] Scott P.J., ‘The Mathematics of Motif Combination and their use for Functional Simulation‘,
International Journal of Machine tools and Manufacture, Vol. 32 (1/2), pp. 203-209, 1992
[72] Bodenschwinna S.U., Mikro-Emo H. and Mikro-Emo S.U., ‘Funktionsgerechte
Rauhheitskennwerte Durch Auswerten der Abbott-Kurve‘, Teil 1-4. Z. Antriebstechnik, Vol. 26,
1987
[73] Fahl C.F., ‘Motif Combination – A New Approach to Surface Profile Analysis‘, Wear, Vol.
83, pp. 165-179, 1982
[75] ASTM E112-96e1, ‘Standard Test Methods for Determining Average Grain Size‘, American
Society for Testing and Materials, 2000
[76] BS 1134-2:1990, ‘Assessment of Surface Texture’, 1990
[77] Waterworth A. and Blunt L., ‘The Effects of a Variation in Modulation Threshold on Surface
Measurements of 2B Stainless Steel‘, Proceedings 8th International Conference on Metrology
and Properties of Engineering Surfaces, 2000
[78] BS EN 13565-3:2000, ‘Geometrical product specifications (GPS) – Surface texture: Profile
method; surfaces having stratified functional properties – Part 3: Height characterisation using
the material probability curve’, 2000
[79] Cao L., Vorburger T.V., Lieberman G., Lettieri T.R., ‘Light-scattering measurement of the
rms slopes of rough surfaces’, International Journal for Applied Optics, Vol.30, pp. 3221-3227,
1991 [80] Wihlborg A., Gunnarsson L., Crafoord R., ‘A factorial design study of coated steel sheets in
a bending-under-tension test’, Proceedings of the 5th International Tribology Conference,
pp537-542, 1998
[81] Chanada Watanatham, Private Communication, 2003
[82] Michigan Metrology, ‘Glossary of Surface Texture Parameters’,
www.michiganmetrology.com.

Depositing User: Sara Taylor
Date Deposited: 20 Dec 2007
Last Modified: 28 Jul 2010 18:21
URI: http://eprints.hud.ac.uk/id/eprint/385

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

Repository Staff Only: item control page

View Item View Item

University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©