Computing and Library Services - delivering an inspiring information environment

UK Health action zones: political accountability and political marketing - perspectives from the South West

Cole, Michael and Cotterill, Lesley (2005) UK Health action zones: political accountability and political marketing - perspectives from the South West. Urban Studies, 42 (3). pp. 397-416. ISSN 0042-0980

[img] PDF
Restricted to Registered users only

Download (170kB)


    This article evaluates the accountability of the strategic layer of Plymouth Health Action Zone (HAZ) and identifies conclusions with a wider application to partnership governance. The structures of Plymouth HAZ are assessed in the context of horizontal, vertical and downward models of accountability. The study finds fundamental weaknesses in the accountability regime. Vertical mechanisms are superficial and often inappropriate. The impact of horizontal accountability is marginalised through factors such as informal networks of dependency and a culture that discourages rigorous scrutiny. Downward accountability is addressed through the dissemination of information about achievements. In particular, the study highlights the difficulties of relying on local partners as the main mechanism of accountability. Plymouth HAZ is also evaluated in relation to political marketing and found to possess a sales-orientation

    Item Type: Article
    Additional Information: © 2005 The Editors of Urban Studies
    Uncontrolled Keywords: UK Health Action Zones Political Accountability Marketing—Perspectives South West Urban Studies
    Subjects: J Political Science > JA Political science (General)
    R Medicine > RA Public aspects of medicine
    Schools: School of Human and Health Sciences

    ADAMS, L., ALCOCK, P. and BROWN, G. (2002)
    Wakefield and District Health Action Zone:
    partnerships and learning, in: L. BAULD and K.
    JUDGE (Eds) Learning from Health Action
    Zones, pp. 85–94. Chichester: Aeneas Press.
    ASHWORTH, R. (2003) Toothless tigers? Councillor
    perceptions of new scrutiny arrangements
    in Welsh local government, Local Government
    Studies, 29(2), pp. 1–18.ASTHANA, S., RICHARDSON, S. and HALLIDAY, J.
    (2002) Partnership working in public policy
    provision: a framework for evaluation, Social
    Policy and Administration, 36(7), pp. 780–795.
    BACHE, I. (2001) Different seeds in the same plot?
    Competing models of capitalism and the incomplete
    contracts of partnership design, Public
    Administration, 79(2), pp. 337–359.
    BARNES, M. and SULLIVAN, H. (2002) Building
    capacity for collaboration in English Health
    Action Zones, in: C. GLENDINNING, M.
    POWELL and K. RUMMERY (Eds) Partnerships,
    New Labour and the Governance of Welfare,
    pp. 81–96. Bristol: The Policy Press.
    BARNES, M., SULLIVAN, H. and MATKA, E. (2003)
    The development of collaborative capacity in
    health action zones: a final report from the
    national evaluation. Birmingham: University
    of Birmingham.
    BAULD, L. and JUDGE, K. (Eds) (2002a) Learning
    from Health Action Zones. Chichester: Aeneas
    BAULD, L. and JUDGE,K. (2002b) The development
    of Health Action Zones, in: L. BAULD and
    K. JUDGE (Eds) Learning from Health Action
    Zones, pp. 1–13. Chichester: Aeneas Press.
    BEETHAM, D. andWEIR, S. (1999) Auditing British
    democracy, The Political Quarterly, 70(2),
    pp. 128–138.
    BENYON, J. and EDWARDS, A. (1999) Community
    governance of crime control, in: G. STOKER
    (Ed.) The New Management of British Local
    Governance, pp. 145–167. London: Macmillan.
    BHATTI, S., CUTHBERT, V. and LUNT, J. (2002)
    The pampering gang project, in: L. BAULD and
    K. JUDGE (Eds) Learning from Health Action
    Zones, pp. 251–262. Chichester: Aeneas Press.
    BOYNE, G. and COLE, M. S. (1996) Fragmentation,
    concentration and local government structure:
    top-tier authorities in England and Wales,
    1831–1996, Government and Policy, 14(4),
    pp. 501–514.
    BOYNE, G. and COLE, M. S. (1998) Revolution,
    evolution and local government structure: an
    empirical analysis of London, Urban Studies,
    35(4), pp. 751–768.
    BRUCE, A. and MCCONNELL, A. (1996) Accountability
    in local government and the NHS, in:
    R. PYPER (Ed.) Aspects of Accountability
    in the British System of Government, pp. 119–
    157. Wirral: Tudor.
    BUTT, R. (1969) The Power of Parliament.
    London: Constable.
    CASTLE, B. (1980) The Castle Diaries 1974–76.
    London: Book Club Associates.
    CLARKE, C., JONES, D., CARR, S. ET AL. (2002)
    Tyne and Wear Health Action Zone evaluation:
    patterns of engagement and entrenchment.
    Newcastle: University of Northumbria.
    CLARKE, J. and GLENDINNING, C. (2002) Partnership
    and the remaking of welfare governance,
    in: C. GLENDINNING, M. POWELL and K.
    RUMMERY (Eds) Partnerships, New Labour
    and the Governance of Welfare, pp. 33–50.
    Bristol: The Policy Press.
    COLE, M. S. (1999) Accountability and quasigovernment:
    the role of parliamentary questions,
    The Journal of Legislative Studies, 5(1),
    pp. 77–101.
    COLE, M. S. (2000) Quangos: UK ministerial
    responsibility in theory and practice, Public
    Policy and Administration, 15(3), pp. 32–45.
    COLE, M. S. (2001) Executive and scrutiny
    reforms: the agenda and its impact at Devon
    County Council, Local Government Studies,
    27(4), pp. 19–34.
    COLE, M. S. (2003a) The Health Action Zone
    initiative: lessons from Plymouth, Local
    Government Studies, 29(3), pp. 99–117.
    COLE, M. S. (2003b) Learning Communities
    report—HAZ: a project evaluation. Department
    of Sociology, University of Plymouth.
    COLE, M. S. (2004) Consultation in local government:
    a case study of practice at Devon County
    Council, Local Government Studies, 30(2), pp.
    CONSIDINE, M. (2002) The end of the line?
    Accountable governance in the age of
    networks, partnerships and joined-up services,
    Governance, 15(1), pp. 21–40.
    COPPEL, D. (2002) Learning from theory-driven
    evaluations across local Health Action Zone
    initiatives in Nottingham: using or losing?, in:
    L. BAULD and K. JUDGE (Eds) Learning from
    Health Action Zones, pp. 199–207. Chichester:
    Aeneas Press.
    COTTERILL, L. (2002) Developing capacity for
    theory-based evaluation, in: L. BAULD and K.
    JUDGE (Eds) Learning from Health Action
    Zones, pp. 117–127. Chichester: Aeneas Press.
    CRAWSHAW, P.,BUNTON, R. andGILLEN, K. (2002)
    Modernisation and Health Action Zones: the
    search for coherence, in: L. BAULD and K.
    JUDGE (Eds) Learning from Health Action
    Zones, pp. 221–230. Chichester: Aeneas Press.
    DABBS, C. (2002) Taking the risk to blossom: the
    Salford Social Entrepreneurs Programme, in:
    L. BAULD and K. JUDGE (Eds) Learning from
    Health Action Zones, pp. 49–60. Chichester:
    Aeneas Press.
    DALY, G. and DAVIS, H. (2002) Partnerships
    for local governance: citizens, communities
    and accountability, in: C. GLENDINNING, M.
    POWELL and K. RUMMERY (Eds) Partnerships,
    New Labour and the Governance of Welfare,
    pp. 97–112. Bristol: The Policy Press.
    DAVIES, J. (2001) Partnerships and Regimes.
    Aldershot: Ashgate.DAVIS, J. (1988) Reforming London. Oxford:
    Clarendon Press.
    DAY, S. and KLEIN, R. (1987) Accountabilities:
    Five Public Services. London: Tavistock.
    Index of Local Deprivation (Regeneration
    Research Summary, No. 15). London: DETR.
    DETR (1998b) Modern local government: in touch
    with the people. London: The Stationery Office.
    DETR (1999) Single Regeneration Budget Round
    5: Regional Framework for Yorkshire and the
    Humber. London: DETR.
    Education Action Zones, in: C. GLENDINNING,
    M. POWELL and K. RUMMERY (Eds) Partnerships,
    New Labour and the Governance of
    Welfare, pp. 183–198. Bristol: The Policy Press.
    DOH (Department of Health) (1997) The new
    NHS: modern, dependable. London: The
    Stationery Office.
    DOH (1998) Modernising social services. London:
    The Stationery Office.
    DOH (2000) The NHS plan. London: The
    Stationery Office.
    DOWDING, K. (1995) Model or metaphor? A
    critical review of the policy network approach,
    Political Studies, 43(1), pp. 136–158.
    DUNLEAVY, P. (1980) Urban Political Analysis.
    London: Macmillan.
    ELCOCK, H. (1998) The changing problem of
    accountability in modern government: an
    analytical agenda for reformers, Public Policy
    and Administration, 13(3), pp. 23–37.
    ELCOCK, H. and HAYWOOD, S. (1980) The buck
    stops where? Accountability and control in the
    National Health Service. Institute for Health
    Studies, University of Hull.
    FARRELL, D. and WORTMANN, M. (1987) Party
    strategies in the electoral market: political
    marketing in West Germany, Britain and
    Ireland, European Journal of Political
    Research, 15, pp. 297–318.
    FEARNLEY, R. (2000) Regenerating the inner city:
    lessons from the UK’s City Challenge experience,
    Social Policy and Administration, 34(5),
    pp. 567–583.
    FINER, S. (1956) The individual responsibility
    of ministers, Public Administration, 34(4),
    pp. 377–396.
    FLINDERS, M. (2001) The Politics of Accountability
    in the Modern State. Aldershot: Ashgate.
    FRANKLIN, B. (1994) Packaging Politics: Political
    Communications in Britain’s Media Democracy.
    London: Edward Arnold.
    (2002) A role for Health Action Zones within
    local strategic partnerships: lessons from the
    South-West, in: L. BAULD and K. JUDGE (Eds)
    Learning from Health Action Zones, pp.
    95–105. Chichester: Aeneas Press.
    HARROP, M. (1990) Political marketing, Parliamentary
    Affairs, 43(3), pp. 277–291.
    HEWART, LORD (1929) The New Despotism.
    London: Benn.
    HIGGINS, J. (1998) HAZs warning: the white
    paper debate, Health Service Journal, 16 April,
    pp. 24–25.
    WICKS, M. (1983) Government and Urban
    Poverty. Oxford: Blackwell.
    HILL, D. (1994) Citizens and Cities. Hemel
    Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
    HILL, D. (2000) Urban Policy and Politics in
    Britain. London: Macmillan.
    HOOD, C. and SCHUPPERT, G. (Eds) (1988) Delivering
    Public Services in Western Europe.
    London: Sage.
    HOOD, C., SCOTT, C., JAMES, O. ET AL. (1999)
    Regulation Inside Government: Wastewatchers,
    Quality Police and Sleaze-busters.
    Oxford: Oxford University Press.
    JENNINGS, I. (1936) Cabinet Government.
    Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
    JOHN, P. (1998) Analysing Public Policy. London:
    KANE, B. (2002) Social capital, health and
    economy in South Yorkshire coalfield communities,
    in: L. Bauld and K. Judge (Eds) Learning
    from Health Action Zones, pp. 187–198.
    Chichester: Aeneas Press.
    KASSIM, H. (1994) Policy networks, networks and
    European Union policy-making: a sceptical view,
    Western European Politics, 17(4), pp. 15–27.
    (Eds) (1997) Managing Complex Networks:
    Strategies for the Public Sector. London: Sage.
    KING, A. (1998) Why Labour won—at last, in: A.
    Labour Triumphs: Britain at the Polls,
    pp. 177–207. Chatham: Chatham House.
    KOTLER, P. and LEVY, S. (1969) Broadening the
    concept of marketing, Journal of Marketing,
    33(1), pp. 10–15.
    LABOUR PARTY (1997) New Labour: because
    Britain deserves better. London: Labour Party.
    LEES-MARSHMENT, J. (2001) Political Marketing
    and British Political Parties: The Party’s Just
    Begun. Manchester: Manchester University
    LOUGHLIN, M. (1996) Understanding central–
    local government relations, Public Policy and
    Administration, 11(2), pp. 48–65.
    LOVELOCK, C. and WEINBERG, C. (1977) Public
    and Nonprofit Marketing: Cases and Readings.
    New York: Scientific Press.
    LOW, S. (1904) The Governance of England.
    MACKINNON, J. (2003) National evaluation of
    Health Action Zones: Merseyside HAZ—a case
    study: final report. Glasgow: University of
    MARSH, D. and RHODES, R. (Eds) (1992a) Policy
    Networks in British Government. Oxford:
    Clarendon Press.
    MARSH, D. and RHODES, R. (Eds) (1992b) Implementing
    Thatcherite Policies. Buckingham:
    Open University Press.
    OATLEY, N. and LAMBERT, C. (1998) Catalyst for
    change: the City Challenge Initiative, in: N.
    OATLEY (Ed.) Cities, Economic Competition
    and Urban Policy, pp. 109–126. London: Paul
    Chapman Publishing.
    PAINTER, C. and CLARENCE, E. (2001) UK Local
    Action Zones and changing urban governance,
    Urban Studies, 38(8), pp. 1215–1232.
    PATON, C. (1999) New Labour’s health policy:
    the new healthcare state, in: M. Powell (Ed.)
    New Labour, New Welfare State?, pp. 51–75.
    Bristol: The Policy Press.
    PATON, C. (2002) Cheques and checks: New
    Labour’s record on the NHS, in: M. Powell
    (Ed.) Evaluating New Labour’s Welfare
    Reforms, pp. 127–143. Bristol: The Policy Press.
    PIKE, M. (2003) Can Do Citizens. London: Social
    Enterprise Services.
    PLYMOUTH HAZ (2002) HAZ project file.
    Plymouth: Plymouth Health Action Zone.
    POWELL, M. (Ed.) (2002) Evaluating New
    Labour’s Welfare Reforms. Bristol: The Policy
    RHODES, J., TYLER, P. and BRENNAN. A. (2003)
    New developments in area-based initiatives
    in England: the experience of the Single
    Regeneration Budget, Urban Studies, 40(8),
    pp. 1399–1426.
    RHODES, R. (1986) The National World of Local
    Government. London: Allen and Unwin.
    RHODES, R. (1988) Beyond Westminster and
    Whitehall. London: Unwin Hyman.
    RHODES, R. (1996) The new governance: governing
    without government, Political Studies,
    44(4), pp. 652–667.
    ROBINSON, F., SHAW, K. ET AL. (2000) Who runs
    the North-East now?: a review and assessment
    of governance in North East England. Department
    of Sociology and Social Policy, University
    of Durham.
    RODRIGO, L. and MUNTON, R. (2002) Addressing
    inequalities in health: education and training as
    a catalyst for change and innovation, in: L.
    BAULD and K. JUDGE (Eds) Learning from
    Health Action Zones, pp. 273–284. Chichester:
    Aeneas Press.
    ROUSE, J. and SMITH, G. (1999) Accountability, in:
    M. POWELL (Ed.) New Labour, New Welfare
    State?, pp. 235–255. Bristol: The Policy Press.
    SCOTT, A., DOWZER, C., POLLARD, J. ET AL. (2002)
    South Yorkshire Coalfields: interim evaluation
    1999–2002—Overview. Published on the
    South Yorkshire Coalfields HAZ website.
    SIMON, E. (1926) A City Council from Within.
    London: Longman.
    SKELCHER, C. (2000) Changing images of the
    state: overloaded, hollowed-out, congested,
    Public Policy and Administration, 15(3),
    pp. 3–19.
    SMITH, B. and HAGUE, D. (Eds) (1971) The
    Dilemma of Accountability in Modern Government.
    London: Macmillan.
    SMITH, M. (1993) Pressure, Power and Policy.
    Hemel Hempstead: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
    SMITH, M. and BEAZLEY, M. (2000) Progressive
    regimes, partnerships and the involvement of
    local communities: a framework for evaluation,
    Public Administration, 78(4), pp. 855–878.
    STEWART, J. (2003) Modernising British Local
    Government. London: Palgrave.
    STOKER, G. (1995) Regime theory and urban politics,
    in: D. JUDGE, G. STOKER and H. WOLMAN
    (Eds) Theories of Urban Politics, pp. 54–71.
    London: Sage.
    STOKER, G. (2004) Transforming Local Governance.
    London: Palgrave.
    STOKER, G. and MOSSBERGER, K. (1994) Urban
    regime theory in comparative perspective,
    Government and Policy, 12(2), pp. 195–212.
    STONE, C. (1993) Urban regimes and the capacity
    to govern: a political economy approach,
    Journal of Urban Affairs, 15, pp. 1–28.
    SULLIVAN, H. (2003) New forms of local accountability:
    coming to terms with ‘many hands’?,
    Policy and Politics, 31(3), pp. 353–369.
    SULLIVAN, H. and SKELCHER, C. (2002) Working
    across Boundaries: Collaboration in Public Services.
    Basingstoke: Palgrave.
    SULLIVAN, H., BARNES, M. and MATKA, E. (2002)
    Building capacity for collaboration in English
    Health Action Zones, in: L. BAULD and
    K. JUDGE (Eds) Learning from Health Action
    Zones, pp. 17–26. Chichester: Aeneas Press.
    TAM, H. (1998) Communitarianism. London:
    TAYLOR, M. (2003) Public Policy in the Community.
    London: Palgrave.
    WALDEGRAVE, W. (1978) The Binding of
    Leviathan. London: Hamish Hamilton.
    WEIR, S. and BEETHAM, D. (1999) Political Power
    and Democratic Control in Britain: The Democratic
    Audit of the United Kingdom. London:
    WEIR, S. and HALL, W. (Eds) (1994) EGO trip.
    London: Charter 88 Trust.
    WILSON, D. and GAME, C. (2002) Local Government
    in the United Kingdom, 3rd edn. Basingstoke:

    Depositing User: Sara Taylor
    Date Deposited: 03 Aug 2007
    Last Modified: 28 Jul 2010 19:20


    Downloads per month over past year

    Repository Staff Only: item control page

    View Item

    University of Huddersfield, Queensgate, Huddersfield, HD1 3DH Copyright and Disclaimer All rights reserved ©